Empedocles
Sicilian poet-philosopher who explained all change as the mixing and separating of four elements under the forces of Love and Strife.
Life
Empedocles came from a prominent family in Acragas (modern Agrigento) in Sicily, and is reported to have been a champion of democracy there, as well as a physician and a wonder-worker. He presents himself in his verses as a divine being in exile.
He wrote in hexameter verse. More of his own words survive than of any other Pre-Socratic. The famous story that he leapt into the crater of Mount Etna is one of several conflicting ancient legends about his death.
Core ideas
- Everything is composed of four “roots”: earth, water, air and fire. These are eternal and unchanging, which answers Parmenides' ban on coming-to-be.
- Two forces, Love and Strife, combine and separate the roots in an endless cosmic cycle.
- Perception works by like recognising like, through effluences that fit the pores of the sense organs.
- The soul undergoes a cycle of reincarnations, and killing animals for food is therefore wrong.
In more depth
Answering Parmenides. Empedocles accepts that nothing comes from nothing and nothing perishes into nothing. What people call birth and death is, he says, only the mixing and separating of things that always exist. These are the four roots: earth, water, air and fire. They are ungenerated and unchanging in themselves, so the Parmenidean rule is kept, yet their combinations in different proportions produce the variety of the world. Bone and blood are given as definite ratios of the roots.
Love and Strife. Mixture and separation need causes, and Empedocles names two: Love, which draws unlike things together, and Strife, which drives them apart. The two prevail in turn in an endless cycle. Under the full rule of Love everything is blended in a sphere; under Strife the roots are wholly separated. A world like ours, with living things in it, exists only in the periods between.
Living things. He describes animals arising from the chance combination of separately formed limbs, with only the viable combinations surviving. Aristotle criticised this for leaving out purpose. Later readers have noticed its resemblance to selection, though Empedocles has no notion of inheritance or gradual change.
The religious poem. The Purifications tells of a divine being exiled for bloodshed and reborn through many lives, and urges abstention from killing animals. How this fits the physics, and whether the fragments come from one poem or two, is disputed; a papyrus published in the 1990s suggests the two themes were more closely joined than was once thought.
The denial of birth and death. Empedocles says there is no birth of any mortal thing and no end in death, only mixing and the exchange of what is mixed; “birth” is the name people give it. He goes on using the ordinary words, he says, by custom. The move became standard: keep the common way of talking, and explain that what it describes is really the combination and separation of permanent things.
Perception and thought. Things give off effluences, fine streams of their own substance, and the sense organs have pores of particular sizes. Perception occurs when an effluence fits a pore. We perceive like by like: earth by the earth in us, water by water, and Love and Strife by the love and strife in us. Thought is located in the blood around the heart, because there the four roots are most evenly blended. It is the first detailed physical theory of perception, and Plato and Aristotle both took it seriously enough to criticise at length.
The clepsydra. To explain breathing, Empedocles compares it to a girl playing with a clepsydra, a vessel with a perforated base used for lifting water. When she covers the top with her hand and dips it, no water enters, because the air inside holds it out; when she lifts her hand, water rushes in. The passage is often cited as an early appeal to a simple observation to show that air, though invisible, is a body that occupies space.
The man. Ancient biography made him a physician, a democratic politician in Acragas, a wonder-worker who checked a plague, and a figure who claimed to walk among his fellow citizens as an immortal god. The legend that he leapt into the crater of Etna is late. The mixture of physics with a doctrine of the exiled soul, which looks strange to modern readers, was natural in a culture where the natural philosopher and the religious healer were not yet distinct roles.
Works
- On Nature (fragments), c. 450 BCE
- Purifications (fragments), c. 450 BCE
Where scholars disagree
Scholars disagree about whether On Nature and Purifications were two poems or parts of a single work.
A common misreading
The four elements are often credited to Aristotle. Empedocles introduced them; Aristotle adopted and reworked the scheme, which then dominated natural philosophy for two thousand years.
Influenced by
Influenced
Schools and eras
Further reading
Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Open Empedocles in the interactive Atlas, with lessons, quizzes, the map and the timeline.