Luce Irigaray
Belgian-born French philosopher of sexual difference, who argued that Western thought has had only one subject, the masculine.
Life
Irigaray trained in philosophy, linguistics and psychoanalysis, and attended the seminars of Jacques Lacan. Her second doctoral thesis, Speculum of the Other Woman, published in 1974, led to her dismissal from her teaching post at Vincennes and her exclusion from Lacan's school. She has since worked as a researcher in Paris and collaborated with women's movements, especially in Italy.
Core ideas
- Western philosophy and psychoanalysis define woman only as the other, the lack or the mirror of man.
- There are two subjects, not one, and sexual difference is the question of our age.
- Women's exclusion is inscribed in language and requires a change in speech itself.
- Mimesis: repeating the tradition's images of woman deliberately, so as to expose them.
- An ethics of sexual difference would let each sex be a limit and a wonder to the other.
In more depth
The speculum. The book reads the philosophers in reverse order, beginning with Freud and ending with Plato's cave. Freud describes the girl as a little man who discovers she lacks something. Irigaray argues that this is not an observation but the pattern of the whole tradition: woman is defined by reference to man, as his negative, his complement, his mirror. A speculum is a curved mirror used to look inside the body. The flat mirror in which man sees himself is replaced by one that shows what the tradition could not see.
Plato's cave. She rereads the cave as a womb. The prisoner's journey upward to the sun and the Forms is a flight from the maternal and material origin toward a purely intelligible father. The matter from which everything comes is left dark and nameless. Philosophy's founding image, on this reading, already contains the forgetting of the mother.
Two, not one. Irigaray does not seek equality if that means women becoming subjects on the model of men. The aim is a culture of two subjects, each with its own relation to language, the body and the divine. This Sex Which Is Not One plays on a title: woman is not a sex, since she is counted as the absence of one, and is not one, since female pleasure and identity are plural. She has proposed specific legal rights for women as women.
The charge of essentialism. Critics, including many feminists, object that speaking of a female way of writing or desiring ties women to their bodies and repeats the old stereotypes. Her defenders reply that her method is strategic mimicry: she takes up the feminine as the tradition has defined it in order to unsettle it. Her later work on wonder draws on René Descartes's account of the first passion, and on Emmanuel Levinas, whom she also criticises.
Works
- Speculum of the Other Woman, 1974
- This Sex Which Is Not One, 1977
- An Ethics of Sexual Difference, 1984
- I Love to You, 1992
Influenced by
Simone de Beauvoir, Martin Heidegger, Emmanuel Levinas, Jacques Derrida, Plato
Influenced
Schools and eras
Post-structuralism, Continental
Further reading
Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Open Luce Irigaray in the interactive Atlas, with lessons, quizzes, the map and the timeline.