Atlas of Philosophy

All entries › Philosophers

Emmanuel Levinas

1906 CE – 1995 CE · Kaunas, Lithuania; Paris, France · European

Lithuanian-born French philosopher who argued that ethics, the responsibility awakened by the face of another person, comes before all other philosophy.

Life

Levinas was born into a Jewish family in Kaunas and went to France to study in 1923. He spent 1928–1929 in Freiburg attending the seminars of Edmund Husserl and Martin Heidegger, and afterwards helped introduce phenomenology to France.

As a French soldier he was captured in 1940 and spent the war in a prisoner-of-war camp. Most of his family in Lithuania were murdered. He directed a Jewish teacher-training college in Paris for many years, became a university professor in his fifties, and also wrote commentaries on the Talmud.

Core ideas

In more depth

Ethics first. Western philosophy, Levinas argues, has been an ontology that reduces the other to the same. To know something is to grasp it under a concept and make it mine. His claim is that the relation to another person comes before knowledge and being. Ethics is first philosophy.

The face. The other person is encountered as a face. By this he does not mean a set of features. The face is the way the other presents himself beyond any idea I can have of him. It expresses, and its first word is a command: you shall not kill. The other is at once destitute, exposed to my power, and placed above me. This relation is not one of knowledge, and it puts my spontaneous freedom in question.

Infinity. He borrows from Descartes the idea of the infinite, a thought that contains more than it can think. The other is infinite in this sense: always in excess of my grasp. Totality is his name for systems that absorb every difference; history and war are its expressions.

Responsibility. I am responsible for the other before any choice or contract. The relation is asymmetrical: I owe the other more than I can claim in return. In his second major work the language becomes more extreme. The self is a hostage, substituted for the other, responsible even for the other's responsibility.

Justice. There is never only one other. The appearance of a third person requires me to compare and weigh, and so gives rise to justice, law and institutions. These remain answerable to the original responsibility.

Objections. Derrida argued that Levinas could not help using the language of being he wanted to leave behind. Others ask whether an infinite obligation can guide action, and have criticised his treatment of the feminine and his comments on political questions.

The life. Levinas was born in Kaunas, Lithuania, to a Jewish family, read the Russian novelists and the Hebrew Bible as a child, and studied in Strasbourg and then Freiburg, where he heard Husserl and Heidegger. He introduced phenomenology to France. A French citizen and soldier, he was captured in 1940 and held in a camp for prisoners of war; his wife and daughter were hidden in a convent, and his parents and brothers were murdered. He dedicated his second major book to the victims.

There is. In early writings Levinas describes a state he calls the “there is”: being with no one in particular who is. Insomnia is his example. In the night one is awake and yet it is not I who watch; it is the night itself that watches, an impersonal rustling without exit. Against Heidegger, for whom being is a gift, Levinas finds bare being oppressive. A subject arises by taking a position and breaking from this anonymity.

Totality. The Western tradition, he argues, has been a philosophy of the same. To know is to grasp, to bring what is other under a concept, a system, a history, where it loses its otherness. Totality is his name for this, and war is its truth: individuals are reduced to bearers of forces. The face of another person is what does not fit. It cannot be made into a theme; it is met in speech, and its first word is a command.

The saying and the said. Otherwise than Being, the later book, distinguishes what is said, a content that can be stated and judged, from the saying, the exposure of one person to another that every statement presupposes. Subjectivity is described in extreme terms: I am hostage to the other, responsible even for his responsibility. He quotes Dostoevsky: each of us is guilty before everyone for everyone, and I more than the others.

The Talmudic readings. Each year Levinas gave a commentary on a passage of the Talmud to a gathering of Jewish intellectuals in Paris. He kept these apart from his philosophy but the themes meet: a God known only in the obligation to the neighbour, and a suspicion of religious enthusiasm. Derrida's long essay Violence and Metaphysics was the first major response to his work.

Works

A common misreading

The “face” in Levinas is not the physical appearance of someone's features. It names the way another person exceeds any image or description and makes a claim on me.

Influenced by

Edmund Husserl, Martin Heidegger, Plato, René Descartes, Søren Kierkegaard

Influenced

Jacques Derrida

Schools and eras

Phenomenology, Continental

Further reading

Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy

Open Emmanuel Levinas in the interactive Atlas, with lessons, quizzes, the map and the timeline.

This page is part of the philosophers list. How this content was made, and its limits, are described in the Terms of use.