Judith Butler
American philosopher who argued that gender is performative and wrote on vulnerability, mourning and nonviolence.
Life
Butler grew up in a Jewish family in Cleveland and first studied philosophy with a rabbi as a teenager. A doctoral thesis at Yale traced the reception of G.W.F. Hegel in twentieth-century France. Gender Trouble, published in 1990, became a founding text of queer theory. Butler has taught at Berkeley since 1993 and is active on questions of war, Israel and Palestine, and the rights of sexual minorities.
Core ideas
- Gender is not something one is but something one does, through repeated acts.
- There is no inner gender identity behind the expressions said to result from it.
- The category of sex is itself shaped by social norms.
- Norms can be exposed and shifted by repeating them differently.
- Lives count as grievable or not according to frames that politics must contest.
In more depth
Performativity. Simone de Beauvoir wrote that one is not born a woman but becomes one. Butler presses the point. Feminists had distinguished sex, a biological fact, from gender, its cultural meaning. But gender is not the expression of an inner core. It is produced by the stylised repetition of acts, gestures and ways of speaking, under social sanction. The term comes from J. L. Austin's performative utterances, which bring about what they name. The effect of a stable identity is the result of the repetition, and because every repetition can go slightly differently, the norms can be altered.
What it does not mean. Readers took the book to say that gender is a costume one can change at will. Butler replied that performance of this kind is not chosen freely: norms precede the subject and form it, and refusing them has costs. Drag is discussed because it shows the imitative structure of all gender, not because it is a model of liberation. In Bodies That Matter the argument extends to sex: which bodily differences count, and how, is itself settled within discourse. Critics, among them Martha Nussbaum, charged that the theory is obscure and offers symbolic gestures in place of politics.
Words that wound. On hate speech Butler argues against relying on the state to prohibit it. A speech act can fail. Because an insult depends on a history of use, it can be taken up and turned, as the word “queer” was. Censorship fixes the injurious meaning and gives power to the courts.
Precarious life. After 2001 the work turns to ethics. All lives are vulnerable and depend on others, but vulnerability is unequally distributed, and some deaths are publicly mourned while others are not counted as losses. Who is grievable shows whose life is taken to be a life. From shared dependency Butler argues for an obligation of nonviolence.
Works
- Gender Trouble, 1990
- Bodies That Matter, 1993
- Excitable Speech, 1997
- Precarious Life, 2004
- The Force of Nonviolence, 2020
Influenced by
Michel Foucault, Simone de Beauvoir, G.W.F. Hegel, Jacques Derrida, J. L. Austin, Emmanuel Levinas
Schools and eras
Post-structuralism, Continental
Further reading
Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Open Judith Butler in the interactive Atlas, with lessons, quizzes, the map and the timeline.