Simone de Beauvoir
French existentialist whose The Second Sex analysed how women are made into “the Other” and founded modern feminist philosophy.
Life
Beauvoir was born into a Parisian bourgeois family and studied philosophy at the Sorbonne, placing second in the national teaching examination of 1929, just behind Jean-Paul Sartre. She taught in schools until 1943, when she turned to writing full time.
She wrote novels, memoirs, travel books and philosophical essays, and co-edited Les Temps modernes. The Second Sex was a scandal on publication in 1949 and was placed on the Vatican's Index. In the 1970s she became active in the French women's movement.
Core ideas
- Woman has been defined as the Other in relation to man, who is taken as the norm.
- Femininity is not a natural essence; it is produced by upbringing, institutions and expectations.
- Human existence is ambiguous: we are at once free subjects and objects for others, and an ethics must accept both.
- My freedom requires the freedom of others.
- Oppression confines people to repetition and denies them the chance to project themselves into an open future.
In more depth
Ambiguity. Beauvoir's ethics starts from the human condition as ambiguous. Each of us is both a free consciousness and a thing among things, both separate and bound to others. Philosophies have tried to deny one side. An existentialist ethics must assume the ambiguity. My freedom needs an open future, and that future depends on other people. To will oneself free is therefore to will others free.
Freedom and situation. She distinguishes the freedom every consciousness has from the concrete power to act. Oppression can so restrict a person's situation that no meaningful project is possible. The oppressed are then not in bad faith. This qualifies Sartre's early view and is her own contribution.
One is not born a woman. The Second Sex opens by asking what a woman is. Its answer is that man has defined himself as the Subject, the essential, and woman as the Other. No biological, psychological or economic destiny fixes the figure that the human female takes on in society. Civilisation as a whole elaborates it. One is not born, but rather becomes, a woman.
Immanence and transcendence. Human existence is transcendence, a going beyond the given through projects. Women have been confined to immanence, to repetition and the maintenance of life. The book's second volume describes how this is lived at each stage, from childhood to old age, with attention to the body, sexuality, marriage and motherhood.
Complicity and liberation. Because the role of Other brings certain securities, women have often accepted it. Liberation requires economic independence and a collective change in institutions, so that the sexes recognise each other as equals.
Reception. Later feminists have criticised her for taking a masculine ideal of transcendence as the norm and for her bleak account of the female body and motherhood. The distinction between sex and gender in later theory derives from her formula. Her originality was long obscured by her association with Sartre.
The life. Beauvoir was raised in a devout bourgeois Paris family and lost her faith at fourteen. In 1929 she placed second in the national philosophy examination, the youngest ever to pass; Sartre was first. They formed a lifelong partnership without marriage or shared household. She taught in lycées until 1943, then lived by writing: novels, essays and four volumes of memoirs. She insisted for years that Sartre was the philosopher, a judgement scholars now reject.
Pyrrhus and Cineas. Her first philosophical essay starts from an anecdote. Pyrrhus lists the lands he will conquer; his adviser Cineas asks, each time, and then? And then we shall rest. Why not rest now? Beauvoir sides with Pyrrhus. A human being is a movement toward ends. But my projects have meaning only if other free people take them up, so I need the freedom of others. I can act for them only by creating starting points, never by doing their good for them.
Ways of failing freedom. The Ethics of Ambiguity sketches characters who evade freedom. The sub-man refuses to engage at all. The serious man treats values as ready-made things and loses himself in a cause. The nihilist, finding no given values, wills nothing. The adventurer enjoys action for its own sake and is indifferent to others. The passionate man fixes on one object. Each begins in childhood, when the world of adults seemed fixed. Genuine freedom wills itself and the freedom of others.
Myth and lived experience. The Second Sex has two volumes. The first examines what biology, psychoanalysis and historical materialism say about women and finds each insufficient, then studies the myths in which woman is nature, mystery, idol and servant. The second follows a woman's life from childhood through marriage, motherhood and old age, drawing on diaries, novels and case reports. The method is phenomenological: it describes how a situation is lived.
Old age and the letter. The Coming of Age applies the same analysis to the old, whom society treats as other and discards once they cease to be useful. In 1971 she signed and helped to organise a public statement by women who declared they had had abortions, then illegal in France. In later interviews she called herself a feminist and said that she no longer believed socialism alone would end women's oppression.
In their words
One is not born, but rather becomes, a woman.
Works
- She Came to Stay, 1943
- The Ethics of Ambiguity, 1947
- The Second Sex, 1949
- The Mandarins, 1954
A common misreading
Beauvoir was long treated as a disciple who applied Sartre's ideas. Scholars now emphasise her independent contributions, some of which, on the weight of situation and on relations with others, influenced him.
Influenced by
Jean-Paul Sartre, G.W.F. Hegel, Edmund Husserl, Martin Heidegger, Mary Wollstonecraft, Karl Marx
Influenced
Schools and eras
Existentialism, Phenomenology, Continental
Further reading
Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Open Simone de Beauvoir in the interactive Atlas, with lessons, quizzes, the map and the timeline.