Atlas of Philosophy

All entries › Philosophers

Jacques Derrida

1930 CE – 2004 CE · El Biar, Algeria; Paris, France · European

French philosopher, born in Algeria, who developed deconstruction as a way of reading the hidden hierarchies in philosophical texts.

Life

Derrida was born into a Jewish family in French Algeria. In 1942, under the Vichy government's anti-Jewish laws, he was expelled from his school. He moved to Paris at nineteen, studied at the École Normale Supérieure, and wrote his early work on Edmund Husserl.

In 1967 he published three books that established his reputation. He taught in Paris and regularly in the United States, where his influence was at first strongest in departments of literature. In later decades he wrote increasingly on ethics, law, politics and religion.

Core ideas

In more depth

The metaphysics of presence. Derrida argues that Western philosophy has consistently privileged presence: the presence of the object to sight, of meaning to consciousness, of the speaker to his own words. It has organised itself by oppositions, such as speech and writing, inside and outside, nature and culture, in which the first term is treated as original and the second as derivative or fallen.

Speech and writing. Since Plato, speech has been taken as the direct expression of thought and writing as a mere copy, useful and dangerous. Derrida shows, in readings of Plato, Rousseau, Saussure and Husserl, that the features these authors assign to writing, such as functioning in the absence of the speaker and being repeatable in new contexts, are conditions of all language, speech included. What was called secondary turns out to be at work in the origin.

Différance. Following Saussure, a sign has its identity only through differences from other signs. Derrida adds that meaning is also always deferred, never fully present in any one element. He coins différance, with an a that is seen and not heard, to join differing and deferring. It is not a concept or a word like others, he says, since it names the movement that makes concepts possible.

Deconstruction. A deconstructive reading works inside a text. It identifies the oppositions the text relies on, shows how the text itself undermines the hierarchy, and displaces the opposition without simply reversing it. The sentence often translated as there is nothing outside the text means that there is no access to a meaning that escapes context and interpretation. It does not deny that there is a world.

Iterability. A sign must be repeatable to be a sign, and so can always be detached from its original context and intention. His exchange with Searle over Austin's theory of speech acts turned on this.

Ethics and politics. His later writing takes up justice, hospitality, forgiveness and democracy. Each, he argues, involves an unconditional demand that cannot be fully met by any rule, and decisions are made in that tension. Justice is not deconstructible.

Reception. Analytic philosophers often charged him with obscurity and with trading on trivial truths or false ones. His readers reply that the difficulty belongs to the attempt to question the language one must use.

The life. Derrida was born in 1930 to a Jewish family near Algiers. In 1942 the Vichy laws expelled him from school. He came to Paris at nineteen, studied at the École Normale Supérieure, and wrote first on Husserl. A lecture at Johns Hopkins in 1966 made him known in America, where his influence in literature departments was greater than in philosophy. In 1992 a proposal to give him an honorary degree at Cambridge was put to a vote after a public letter of protest; it passed.

Plato's pharmacy. In the Phaedrus an Egyptian god offers the king the invention of writing as a remedy for memory. The king replies that it is a poison: people will rely on marks outside themselves and forget. The Greek word used, pharmakon, means both remedy and poison. Derrida argues that translators who choose one sense erase what the text is doing. Plato condemns writing in favour of living speech, yet describes true speech as writing in the soul.

The supplement. Rousseau calls writing a supplement to speech, as he calls education a supplement to nature. A supplement is an addition to something complete. But if the thing can be added to, it was lacking. Derrida follows this logic through Rousseau's texts and concludes that what is presented as original and whole always turns out to need what is called secondary. The much-quoted sentence that there is nothing outside the text means that there is no access to a meaning free of this play of references.

Signature and context. Reading Austin on speech acts, Derrida observes that a promise or a signature works only if it can be repeated in other contexts, including on a stage or as a forgery. The possibility of the non-serious case is therefore not an accident to be set aside. It is a condition of the serious one. John Searle replied sharply, and the exchange became a landmark of the mutual incomprehension of two traditions.

The gift and the animal. Later work examines concepts that seem to undo themselves. A pure gift would have to be given without return and without even being recognised as a gift, or it becomes exchange. Forgiveness worthy of the name forgives the unforgivable. Hospitality without condition would not ask the guest's name. In a late lecture he describes standing naked before the gaze of his cat and asks what philosophy has assumed in speaking of “the animal”.

Works

Where scholars disagree

Derrida's reception was unusually polarised. An exchange with John Searle in the 1970s, and a 1992 letter from analytic philosophers opposing a Cambridge honorary degree, are well-known episodes.

A common misreading

“There is nothing outside the text” is commonly taken to mean that only words exist. Derrida explained that he meant there is nothing outside context: nothing is available to us independently of some web of signs and interpretation.

Influenced by

Edmund Husserl, Martin Heidegger, Friedrich Nietzsche, Emmanuel Levinas, Plato, Hans-Georg Gadamer

Related ideas

Deconstruction

Schools and eras

Post-structuralism, Phenomenology, Continental

Further reading

Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy

Open Jacques Derrida in the interactive Atlas, with lessons, quizzes, the map and the timeline.

This page is part of the philosophers list. How this content was made, and its limits, are described in the Terms of use.