Martha Nussbaum
American philosopher who developed the capabilities approach and a cognitive account of the emotions.
Life
Nussbaum trained as a classicist at Harvard, having first studied theatre, and wrote on Aristotle and Greek tragedy. In the 1980s she worked with Amartya Sen at a United Nations research institute in Helsinki. She has taught at Harvard, Brown and, since 1995, the University of Chicago, in law and philosophy.
Core ideas
- A good human life is vulnerable to luck, and that vulnerability is part of its value.
- Emotions are judgements about things we care about and do not fully control.
- A just society secures for each person a threshold level of ten central capabilities.
- Justice must extend to people with disabilities, to citizens of other nations, and to animals.
- Literature and the arts are necessary to moral and civic education.
In more depth
Fragility. Greek tragedy shows good people ruined by events they could not control: Hecuba, who loses everything and becomes savage, or Agamemnon, forced to choose between his daughter and his army. Plato responded by seeking a good that nothing could touch. Aristotle, as Nussbaum reads him, accepted that a life rich in friendship, love and political activity is exposed to loss, and that a life made invulnerable would be poorer. The book argues for the second view.
The list. The capabilities approach asks of each person: what is she actually able to do and to be? Nussbaum gives a list of ten central capabilities: life; bodily health; bodily integrity; senses, imagination and thought; emotions; practical reason; affiliation; concern for other species; play; and control over one's political and material environment. Each person is to be treated as an end, and a government has failed if any citizen falls below the threshold on any item. The list is meant to be open to revision and to command agreement among people of different outlooks.
Emotions as judgements. Drawing on the Stoics, Nussbaum holds that an emotion is an appraisal: grief is the recognition that someone of great importance to me is gone. Emotions are therefore intelligent and can be true or false to the facts. Unlike the Stoics she does not conclude that they should be removed, since the attachments they register are worth having. She has examined particular emotions in law and politics, arguing that disgust and shame are unreliable guides, and that anger, with its wish for payback, is usually a mistake.
Three frontiers. Social contract theories, including John Rawls's, picture justice as a bargain among rough equals for mutual advantage. Nussbaum argues that this leaves out those who cannot bargain on equal terms: people with severe disabilities, the citizens of poor countries, and non-human animals. Capabilities, which start from what a dignified life requires, can cover them.
Works
- The Fragility of Goodness, 1986
- Women and Human Development, 2000
- Upheavals of Thought, 2001
- Frontiers of Justice, 2006
- Creating Capabilities, 2011
Influenced by
Aristotle, Amartya Sen, John Rawls, Bernard Williams, Seneca
Related ideas
Schools and eras
Further reading
Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Open Martha Nussbaum in the interactive Atlas, with lessons, quizzes, the map and the timeline.