Atlas of Philosophy

All entries › Ideas

Moral luck

The problem that we judge people for things that depend on factors outside their control.

Explanation

Two drivers are equally careless. A child runs in front of one of them and is killed; the other gets home without incident. We blame the first far more, and he will blame himself more. Yet the difference between them was luck. This conflicts with the common conviction, stated most firmly by Immanuel Kant, that moral worth depends only on what is within a person's control.

Bernard Williams introduced the term in 1976 with the case of a painter who abandons his family to pursue his art, and whose decision can be justified only by a success he cannot guarantee. Thomas Nagel distinguished four kinds: luck in how things turn out, in the circumstances one faces, in the character one has, and in the causes of one's will. Follow the argument through and nothing seems left for which a person is responsible.

Critics

Some deny that there is moral luck: the two drivers are equally blameworthy, and we merely have more evidence about one. Others accept it and give up the control principle.

Immanuel Kant

Where scholars disagree

The law's different treatment of attempted and completed crimes is a standing practical case.

Originator

Bernard Williams

Related ideas

Moral responsibility, Compatibilism, Deontology

Further reading

Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy

Open Moral luck in the interactive Atlas, with lessons, quizzes, the map and the timeline.

This page is part of the ideas list. How this content was made, and its limits, are described in the Terms of use.