Atlas of Philosophy

All entries › Philosophers

Isaiah Berlin

1909 CE – 1997 CE · Riga, Latvia; Oxford, England · European

Historian of ideas and liberal thinker who distinguished two concepts of liberty and defended the plurality of values.

Life

Berlin was born to a Jewish timber merchant's family in Riga and as a boy saw the revolutions of 1917 in Petrograd. The family came to England in 1921. He was the first Jew elected to a fellowship at All Souls College. During the war he reported on American opinion from Washington, and in 1945 he met the poet Anna Akhmatova in Leningrad. He was the founding president of Wolfson College, Oxford.

Core ideas

In more depth

Two concepts. Negative liberty answers the question: how wide is the area within which I am left to do as I choose? Positive liberty answers: who governs me? The second begins innocently, as the wish to be moved by my own reasons. But it invites a division of the self into a higher, rational self and a lower one of passion. Once that is granted, others may claim to know what my real self wants and to force me for my own good. Berlin traces this path through Rousseau and Hegel to the dictatorships of his century. He does not reject positive liberty; he warns of its perversion.

Pluralism. Liberty, equality, justice, mercy, loyalty and knowledge are all real goods, and they collide. More liberty for some may mean less equality; mercy may defeat justice. There is no common measure by which the conflict can be settled once and for all, so choices involve real loss. Berlin held that this is a fact about values and not a sign of our ignorance. He distinguished it from relativism: the ends people pursue are limited in number and intelligible to one another.

The crooked timber. The belief that all good things must fit together in one harmonious whole, which can be discovered and then realised, Berlin regarded as the oldest and most dangerous idea in Western thought. If a perfect society is possible, no price is too high to pay for it. He took a line from Kant as a motto: out of the crooked timber of humanity no straight thing was ever made. The lesson is to keep an uneasy balance and to avoid extremes of suffering.

The Counter-Enlightenment. Much of his work is portraiture of thinkers who rebelled against the rationalism of their age: Vico, Herder, Hamann, de Maistre. Berlin did not share their politics. He thought they had seen what the Enlightenment missed: that cultures differ in their ideals and each must be understood from within. Critics ask whether pluralism really supports liberalism, since liberty would then be only one value among many.

Works

Influenced by

John Stuart Mill, Immanuel Kant, Giambattista Vico, Niccolò Machiavelli, David Hume

Influenced

Bernard Williams, John Rawls

Schools and eras

Analytic

Further reading

Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy

Open Isaiah Berlin in the interactive Atlas, with lessons, quizzes, the map and the timeline.

This page is part of the philosophers list. How this content was made, and its limits, are described in the Terms of use.