Giambattista Vico
Neapolitan thinker who held that we can know history because we made it, and proposed a science of the development of nations.
Life
Vico was the son of a bookseller in Naples. A fall in childhood fractured his skull and kept him from school for years, and he was largely self-taught. He held the poorly paid chair of rhetoric at the university for over forty years and failed to win the chair of law. He sold a ring to pay for printing the New Science, which went largely unread in his lifetime.
Core ideas
- The true and the made are convertible: we fully know only what we ourselves have made.
- The world of nations was made by human beings, so its principles can be found in the human mind.
- Nations pass through ages of gods, heroes and men, and may fall back into barbarism.
- Early peoples thought in poetry and myth, by imaginative universals.
- Institutions arise from actions aimed at narrow ends, guided by providence.
In more depth
Against Descartes. René Descartes held that clear and distinct ideas are the mark of truth and that mathematics is the model of knowledge. Vico replied that we are certain in geometry because we make it: its objects are our own constructions. Physics cannot be known in that way, for God made nature. And the cogito gives consciousness of my existence, not knowledge of its cause. The criterion of truth is to have made the thing. From this follows a conclusion Descartes would have rejected: history, law and language, being human works, are more knowable than nature.
The three ages. Every nation, Vico argues, runs an ideal course. In the age of gods, people terrified by thunder imagined a sky that spoke, and lived under religion and the rule of fathers. In the age of heroes, aristocracies governed by force and custom, and spoke in emblems and epic. In the age of men, reason recognised human equality, and law and prose developed. Refinement then decays into a barbarism of reflection, in which each thinks only of his own interest, and the cycle may begin again.
Poetic wisdom. The first peoples were not philosophers who hid truths in fables. They were poets by necessity, who thought in images because they could not yet abstract. Jove is the sky experienced as a living power; Achilles is the idea of courage as a person. Homer was not one man but the Greek people telling their history in song. To understand the past we must enter, with great effort, a mentality unlike our own. This idea made Vico a founder of the historical study of culture, recognised only in the nineteenth century.
Works
- On the Study Methods of Our Time, 1709
- On the Most Ancient Wisdom of the Italians, 1710
- The New Science, 1725; revised 1730 and 1744
Influenced by
Plato, Francis Bacon, René Descartes
Influenced
Isaiah Berlin, Karl Marx, G.W.F. Hegel
Schools and eras
Further reading
Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Open Giambattista Vico in the interactive Atlas, with lessons, quizzes, the map and the timeline.