Arthur Schopenhauer
German pessimist who held that the inner nature of the world is a blind, striving will, and that life is consequently suffering.
Life
Schopenhauer was born in Danzig to a wealthy merchant family, and an inheritance left him financially independent. He published his main work, The World as Will and Representation, at thirty. As a lecturer in Berlin he scheduled his classes against G.W.F. Hegel's, drew almost no students, and abandoned teaching.
From 1833 he lived alone in Frankfurt, following a fixed daily routine. Recognition came only in his last decade, after a collection of essays, Parerga and Paralipomena, found a wide readership.
Core ideas
- The world we experience is representation, structured by space, time and causality, as Immanuel Kant taught.
- The thing in itself is will: an aimless striving that we know directly in our own bodies.
- Because willing is endless and satisfaction brief, existence is predominantly suffering.
- Aesthetic contemplation, especially of music, gives temporary release from the will.
- Morality springs from compassion, and lasting release comes through denial of the will.
In more depth
Representation. Schopenhauer begins from Kant: the world we experience is appearance, ordered by the forms the mind brings to it. He reduces these to space, time and causality, united in the principle of sufficient reason. The world is my representation. Every object exists only for a subject.
Will. Kant held that the thing in itself cannot be known. Schopenhauer claims there is one point of access. I know my body in two ways: from outside, as an object among objects, and from inside, as will. What appears as a bodily movement is, seen from within, an act of will. He extends this to everything: the inner nature of all things is will, a blind striving without goal or end. Individual things are its appearances in space and time, which are the principle of individuation.
Pessimism. Because willing arises from lack, life is mostly suffering. A satisfied desire gives way to a new one or to boredom, so life swings like a pendulum between pain and boredom. The will is one in all, so it preys on itself. This is the worst of possible worlds that could still exist.
Art. Release is possible. In aesthetic contemplation the subject is for a time freed from willing and becomes a pure knower, absorbed in the object. Art presents the timeless Ideas. Music stands apart from the other arts, since it copies the will itself, which explains its direct effect on feeling.
Ethics. Egoism rests on the illusion that individuals are truly separate. Compassion, the only source of actions with moral worth, is the felt recognition that another's suffering is one's own. He attacks Kant's ethics of duty as theological morality in disguise.
Denial of the will. The final deliverance is the will's turning against itself in asceticism, as seen in the saints of every religion. He found his conclusions anticipated in the Upanishads and Buddhism. Critics ask how the will, if it is everything, can deny itself, and how he can know the thing in itself at all.
Influence. Wagner, the young Nietzsche, Freud and the early Wittgenstein all owe him a debt.
The fourfold root. Schopenhauer's doctoral dissertation, which he insisted must be read first, distinguishes four forms of the principle that nothing is without a reason: the reason of becoming, which is causality among physical objects; the reason of knowing, which is logical ground; the reason of being, which governs space and time in mathematics; and the reason of acting, which is motivation. The principle applies only within experience. It cannot be used to ask for the cause of the world as a whole.
The body as key. Everything else I know only from outside, as representation. My own body I know in two ways: as an object among objects, and from within, as will. An act of will and the movement of the body are not cause and effect. They are one thing given twice. Schopenhauer extends this by analogy: what I find in myself as will is the inner nature of every appearance, from the fall of a stone to the growth of a plant. He calls this the single thought of his book.
The pendulum and the porcupines. Life swings, he says, like a pendulum between pain and boredom: want is suffering, and its satisfaction quickly becomes tedium. Happiness is negative, only the brief absence of pain. A late fable describes porcupines on a cold day who crowd together for warmth, prick one another, move apart, and grow cold again, until they find a moderate distance. So it is with human society, where politeness is the distance.
Music and compassion. The other arts copy the Ideas; music copies the will itself, which is why it speaks so directly. Melody tells the story of striving and satisfaction. In ethics, the compassionate person sees through the difference between self and other, which belongs only to appearance: the Sanskrit formula “that art thou” expresses it. He kept a bust of the Buddha in his study and was among the first European philosophers to take Indian thought seriously.
Late fame. The main work of 1818 was ignored. Schopenhauer lectured in Berlin at the same hour as Hegel and drew almost no students. He lived for decades as a private scholar in Frankfurt and became famous only in the 1850s, through a collection of essays, Parerga and Paralipomena.
Works
- On the Fourfold Root of the Principle of Sufficient Reason, 1813
- The World as Will and Representation, published late 1818, dated 1819; enlarged 1844
- On the Basis of Morality, 1840
- Parerga and Paralipomena, 1851
A common misreading
Schopenhauer is sometimes said to have derived his system from Indian philosophy. He encountered the Upanishads and Buddhist ideas while writing it and welcomed them as confirmation, but its framework comes from Kant and Plato.
Influenced by
Immanuel Kant, Plato, George Berkeley
Influenced
Friedrich Nietzsche, Ludwig Wittgenstein
Schools and eras
Further reading
Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Open Arthur Schopenhauer in the interactive Atlas, with lessons, quizzes, the map and the timeline.