Atlas of Philosophy

All entries › Ideas

The regress of justification

The problem that every reason seems to need a further reason.

Also known as: Agrippa's trilemma, Foundationalism and coherentism

Explanation

Ask why you believe something and you give a reason. Ask why you accept the reason and you give another. The chain seems to have three possible shapes. It goes on for ever; it stops at something for which no reason is given; or it circles back on itself. The ancient sceptics, as Sextus Empiricus reports, argued that none of the three yields justification.

Each option has become a theory. Foundationalism holds that some beliefs are justified without support from other beliefs, as René Descartes held of the cogito and empiricists of reports of present experience. Coherentism holds that beliefs support one another in a web, and that justification belongs to the whole. Infinitism accepts the endless chain.

Critics

Against foundations it is said that nothing is simply given without interpretation. Against coherence, that a consistent fairy tale would count as justified. Ludwig Wittgenstein suggested that the chain ends in ways of acting, not in beliefs.

W.V.O. Quine, Ludwig Wittgenstein

Where scholars disagree

Externalists deny that the believer must have access to what justifies a belief at all, which would dissolve the regress.

Originator

Sextus Empiricus

Related ideas

The Gettier problem, The brain in a vat, The Cogito

Further reading

Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy

Open The regress of justification in the interactive Atlas, with lessons, quizzes, the map and the timeline.

This page is part of the ideas list. How this content was made, and its limits, are described in the Terms of use.