The Gettier problem
The problem, raised by counterexamples, of saying what must be added to justified true belief to make knowledge.
Explanation
From Plato onward a common analysis held that someone knows a thing when they believe it, it is true, and they have good reason for it. In a three-page paper of 1963, Edmund Gettier gave cases that meet all three conditions and are not knowledge. Smith has strong evidence that Jones owns a Ford and infers: either Jones owns a Ford or Brown is in Barcelona. Jones in fact owns no Ford, and by sheer chance Brown is in Barcelona. Smith's belief is true and justified, yet he does not know it.
A simpler case: you look at a clock that reads noon, and it is noon, but the clock stopped twelve hours ago. The lesson is that justification and truth can come together by luck.
Critics
Proposed repairs add a fourth condition: no false premises, no defeating evidence, a causal link to the fact, or, with Robert Nozick, that the belief track the truth. Each has met new counterexamples. Some conclude that knowledge cannot be analysed and should be taken as basic.
Where scholars disagree
Similar cases appear earlier in Indian and medieval philosophy. Whether the search for an analysis was misguided is itself debated.
Related ideas
The regress of justification, The brain in a vat, A priori knowledge
Further reading
Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Open The Gettier problem in the interactive Atlas, with lessons, quizzes, the map and the timeline.