Atlas of Philosophy

All entries › Ideas

The brain in a vat

The sceptical scenario that all one's experience is fed to a disembodied brain by a computer.

Explanation

Suppose a brain is kept alive in a vat of nutrients and connected to a computer that supplies exactly the signals a body would. Its experiences would be just like yours. How then do you know you are not such a brain? If you cannot rule it out, the sceptic argues, you do not know that you have hands. The case is a modern form of René Descartes's deceiving demon.

Hilary Putnam gave a surprising reply in 1981. Words refer to things through causal contact with them. A brain that has always been in a vat has never been in contact with brains or vats, so its word “vat” would not refer to vats. Its thought “I am a brain in a vat” would therefore be false. So the sentence cannot be truly thought by anyone.

Critics

Critics reply that Putnam's argument does not cover a brain placed in a vat recently, and that even if I cannot truly say the sentence, my situation may still be as bad. G.E. Moore's response to scepticism runs the argument backwards: I know I have hands, so I am not a brain in a vat.

Thomas Nagel

Where scholars disagree

Whether knowledge requires ruling out such scenarios, or only the relevant alternatives, divides theories of knowledge.

Originator

Hilary Putnam

Related ideas

The Cogito, The Gettier problem, The regress of justification

Further reading

Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy

Open The brain in a vat in the interactive Atlas, with lessons, quizzes, the map and the timeline.

This page is part of the ideas list. How this content was made, and its limits, are described in the Terms of use.