Thomas Nagel
American philosopher whose work turns on the conflict between the subjective point of view and the objective one.
Life
Nagel was born in Belgrade to German Jewish refugees and grew up in New York. He studied at Cornell, Oxford and Harvard, where John Rawls supervised his thesis, and taught at Princeton and then for decades at New York University.
Core ideas
- An organism has conscious states if and only if there is something it is like to be that organism.
- The objective view of the world leaves out the subjective character of experience.
- Reasons for action can be objective: the fact that someone is in pain is a reason for anyone to help.
- Life is absurd because we can step back and doubt what we cannot help taking seriously.
- Moral luck: we are judged for much that is beyond our control.
In more depth
The bat. Bats perceive the world by echolocation, a sense unlike any of ours. We can imagine hanging upside down and catching insects, but that tells us what it would be like for us to behave as a bat does. It does not tell us what it is like for a bat to be a bat. The facts about that are accessible only from a particular type of point of view. Physical science proceeds by leaving points of view behind. So it is a mystery how the physical account could capture them. Nagel does not conclude that physicalism is false, only that we do not at present understand how it could be true.
The view from nowhere. We can form a conception of the world in which we ourselves appear as one item among others. This detached view is the source of science and of impartial morality. But we remain particular creatures with our own lives. Nagel treats one problem after another, including free will, personal identity, knowledge and ethics, as a collision between these two standpoints. His advice is to resist both the reduction of the subjective and the denial of the objective, and to live with the tension.
The absurd. People say life is absurd because we are small or will die. Nagel replies that being large or immortal would not help. The source is in us: we pursue our lives with seriousness, and we can also step back and see that seriousness as arbitrary. The two attitudes collide. He recommends irony over the defiance urged by Albert Camus.
Death and altruism. If death is the end, why is it bad for the one who dies? Because it deprives them of the goods of life, and a loss need not be felt to be a loss. In his first book he argued that prudence, caring about one's own future, and altruism, caring about others, have the same structure: each requires seeing the present self as one among many, equally real. In 2012 he argued that materialist Darwinism cannot account for consciousness, reason and value, a claim that drew sharp criticism from scientists.
In their words
An organism has conscious mental states if and only if there is something that it is like to be that organism.
Works
- The Possibility of Altruism, 1970
- What Is It Like to Be a Bat?, 1974
- Mortal Questions, 1979
- The View from Nowhere, 1986
- Mind and Cosmos, 2012
Influenced by
John Rawls, Immanuel Kant, Ludwig Wittgenstein
Influenced
Related ideas
The hard problem of consciousness, Moral luck
Schools and eras
Further reading
Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Open Thomas Nagel in the interactive Atlas, with lessons, quizzes, the map and the timeline.