Alexis de Tocqueville
French political thinker who analysed democracy as a social condition of equality, with its promise and its dangers.
Life
Tocqueville came from an old Norman noble family; his parents narrowly escaped the guillotine. In 1831 he and a friend travelled for nine months in the United States, officially to study prisons. Democracy in America made him famous at thirty. He sat in the French parliament, served briefly as foreign minister in 1849, and withdrew from politics after the coup of Louis-Napoleon.
Core ideas
- Democracy is above all equality of conditions, and its advance is irresistible.
- The majority can tyrannise over minorities and over thought itself.
- Individualism leads citizens to withdraw into private life and leave public affairs to the state.
- Equality may produce a mild, administrative despotism that keeps people in perpetual childhood.
- Associations, local self-government and religion counteract these dangers.
In more depth
Equality of conditions. What struck Tocqueville in America was not its constitution but the absence of fixed ranks. This equality shapes everything: manners, family, ideas, ambitions. He believed the same movement had been under way in Europe for seven hundred years and treated it as a fact willed by providence. The question was not whether to have democracy but whether it would be free or servile. America showed that it could be free, and he studied how.
Tyranny of the majority. In a democracy the majority makes the laws, forms public opinion and chooses the officials. A person wronged by it has nowhere to turn. More subtly, the majority draws a circle around thought. Within it a writer is free; outside it he is not burned but shunned. Tocqueville said he knew of no country with less independence of mind and real freedom of discussion than America. John Stuart Mill reviewed the book and took the idea into On Liberty.
Soft despotism. Near the end he imagines a new kind of oppression. Above a crowd of similar and equal people, each withdrawn into a small circle of family and friends, rises an immense tutelary power that provides for their security, foresees their needs and manages their affairs. It does not break wills; it softens and guides them, and reduces each nation to a flock of timid and industrious animals. The remedy is the practice of freedom in small things: the township, the jury, the voluntary association, where people learn to act together.
The old regime. His second great book argues that the Revolution continued what the monarchy had begun. The kings had already destroyed local liberties and concentrated power in Paris. He also observed that revolutions break out not when conditions are worst but when they are improving and expectations rise.
Works
- Democracy in America, 1835, 1840
- Recollections, written 1850–1851
- The Old Regime and the Revolution, 1856
Influenced by
Montesquieu, Jean-Jacques Rousseau, Blaise Pascal
Influenced
John Stuart Mill, Hannah Arendt
Schools and eras
Further reading
Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Open Alexis de Tocqueville in the interactive Atlas, with lessons, quizzes, the map and the timeline.