Hannah Arendt
German-born political thinker who analysed totalitarianism, the nature of political action and the thoughtlessness that enables great evil.
Life
Arendt grew up in a secular Jewish family in Königsberg and studied with Martin Heidegger, Edmund Husserl and Karl Jaspers. She fled Germany in 1933 after a brief arrest, worked in Paris for Jewish refugee organisations, was interned in 1940, escaped, and reached New York in 1941.
She became an American citizen and taught at Chicago and the New School for Social Research. Her report on the 1961 trial of the Nazi official Adolf Eichmann caused lasting controversy.
Core ideas
- Totalitarianism is a new form of government, based on ideology and terror, that aims to make human beings superfluous.
- The active life has three parts: labour, work and action. Action, speaking and acting among equals, is the properly political one.
- Each birth brings the capacity to begin something new (“natality”).
- Power arises when people act together and is the opposite of violence.
- The “banality of evil”: Eichmann's crimes came from a failure to think, not from demonic motives.
In more depth
Totalitarianism. Arendt argued that Nazism and Stalinism were a new form of government, distinct from older tyrannies. Their essence is terror directed by an ideology that claims to know the law of history or nature. They aim at total domination, the elimination of spontaneity, and found their fullest expression in the camps. They arise from masses of isolated individuals who have lost a common world.
The active life. The Human Condition distinguishes three activities. Labour answers to the necessities of biological life and leaves nothing behind. Work builds a durable world of objects. Action, which includes speech, takes place directly between people and discloses who each one is. It corresponds to plurality, the fact that men, not Man, inhabit the earth.
Action and its remedies. To act is to begin something new; she calls this capacity natality. Action is unpredictable and irreversible, since it sets off processes among other free agents. The remedies are human too: forgiveness releases from the past, and promising binds the future.
The public realm. Politics is the space of appearance where people act together. Power arises from acting in concert and is different from violence, which can destroy power but never create it. She held that the modern age has allowed labour and economic administration, the social, to crowd out the political.
The banality of evil. Reporting on the trial of Adolf Eichmann, she described a man who was neither a monster nor a fanatic. He spoke in clichés and showed an inability to think from another's standpoint. The phrase caused lasting controversy, as did her remarks on the Jewish councils. Historians have since argued that Eichmann was more ideologically committed than she saw.
Thinking and judging. Her last, unfinished work asked whether the activity of thinking, the silent dialogue of oneself with oneself, is among the conditions that make people abstain from evil.
Criticism. Her sharp separation of the political from the social has been found to exclude questions of poverty and race from politics.
The life. Arendt was born in Hanover and raised in Königsberg, studied with Heidegger, with whom she had an affair, and wrote her dissertation on love in Augustine under Jaspers. Arrested briefly in 1933, she fled to Paris, worked for organisations helping Jewish refugees, was interned in France in 1940, escaped, and reached New York in 1941. She was stateless for eighteen years. She declined to be called a philosopher and described her field as political theory.
The right to have rights. From her own experience she drew a conclusion about human rights. The stateless of the interwar years had lost their place in any political community, and the supposedly inalienable rights of man turned out to be unenforceable the moment people were only human. Before any particular right comes the right to have rights: to belong to a community in which one's actions and opinions matter. Camps were preceded by making people superfluous.
Natality. Because each person is new, human beings can begin something. Arendt calls this natality and sets it against the emphasis on mortality in the philosophical tradition. Action is beginning, and its results cannot be predicted or undone. Two capacities answer these frailties: forgiving, which releases us from what we have done, and promising, which sets islands of security in the uncertain future. Politics depends on both.
Power and violence. Power, in her account, arises whenever people act together and vanishes when they disperse. It is not the possession of a ruler. Violence is instrumental and can destroy power, but it cannot create it; rule by sheer violence comes into play where power is being lost. On Revolution contrasts the American Revolution, which founded lasting institutions of freedom, with the French, which was overwhelmed by the social question of poverty.
The controversy. Eichmann in Jerusalem brought fierce attack for the phrase about the banality of evil and for her remarks on the cooperation of Jewish councils. Asked by Gershom Scholem whether she lacked love for the Jewish people, she replied that she loved only her friends. The question of thoughtlessness led to her last work, on whether the activity of thinking is among the conditions that make people abstain from evil.
Works
- The Origins of Totalitarianism, 1951
- The Human Condition, 1958
- Eichmann in Jerusalem, 1963
- The Life of the Mind, published posthumously, 1978
Where scholars disagree
Historians have challenged her portrait of Eichmann, citing evidence that he was a committed antisemite. Whether that undermines her general thesis is debated. Arendt also declined to call herself a philosopher, preferring “political theorist”.
A common misreading
“The banality of evil” does not mean that the Holocaust was ordinary or that Eichmann was merely following orders. Arendt's claim concerned the shallowness of the perpetrator, not the scale or nature of the crime.
Influenced by
Martin Heidegger, Immanuel Kant, Aristotle, Augustine of Hippo
Influenced
Schools and eras
Further reading
Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Open Hannah Arendt in the interactive Atlas, with lessons, quizzes, the map and the timeline.