Pyrrho
The figurehead of ancient scepticism, who taught that tranquillity follows from holding no opinions about how things really are.
Life
Pyrrho began as a painter in Elis in the western Peloponnese. He travelled with Alexander the Great's expedition as far as India, where ancient sources say he encountered “naked wise men”. On his return he lived quietly and was honoured by his city.
He wrote nothing. His outlook was recorded by his pupil Timon of Phlius, whose works survive only in fragments, and the later sceptical school that took his name may have reshaped his views considerably.
Core ideas
- Things are in themselves indeterminate; our perceptions and opinions are neither true nor false.
- We should therefore hold no opinions and say of each thing that it no more is than is not.
- The result of this attitude is freedom from disturbance (ataraxia).
In more depth
The evidence. Pyrrho wrote nothing. The main testimony is a summary by his pupil Timon, which survives at third hand. According to it, anyone who wants to be happy must consider three things: what things are like, how we should be disposed toward them, and what will result.
The three answers. Things, Timon reports, are equally indifferent, unmeasurable and undecidable. So neither our sensations nor our opinions tell the truth or lie, and we should not trust them but be without opinions, saying of each thing that it no more is than is not. The result is first speechlessness and then freedom from disturbance.
Two readings. The passage can be read as a claim about the world, that things themselves have no definite nature, which would make Pyrrho a dogmatic metaphysician of indeterminacy. Or it can be read as a claim about our knowledge, that we cannot determine what things are like. The later Pyrrhonists, who took his name, plainly held only the second kind of view, and suspended judgement even on that.
Living without belief. Ancient critics said that a person with no beliefs could not act. Stories that Pyrrho had to be saved by friends from cliffs and carts make the point as a joke; other reports say he lived prudently to nearly ninety. The later sceptics answered that one can follow appearances, feelings and custom without asserting that they are true.
The journey east. Pyrrho began as a painter and travelled with the army of Alexander as far as India. There, the sources say, he met the “naked wise men” and was impressed by their indifference to pain and circumstance. Some modern scholars have argued for a real debt to Indian thought, pointing to resemblances between the three-part formula of Timon and Buddhist teaching. The evidence does not settle the matter, but the journey is the best-attested contact between Greek and Indian philosophers.
Tranquillity first. In the sources the aim is always practical: to be free of disturbance. Pyrrho's fame in his own city came from his manner of life. He is said to have been calm in a storm at sea, pointing to a pig that went on eating as the model for a wise man, and to have endured surgery without flinching. His city honoured him and exempted philosophers from taxes on his account. The theory was valued because of the person.
From Pyrrho to Pyrrhonism. Pyrrho left no school. For two centuries scepticism was carried on in Plato's Academy by Arcesilaus and Carneades, who argued against the Stoic claim to certain knowledge. In the first century BCE Aenesidemus broke with the Academy, which he thought had grown dogmatic, and revived a more radical scepticism under Pyrrho's name. The detailed Pyrrhonism of Sextus Empiricus descends from Aenesidemus, and how much of it goes back to Pyrrho himself is uncertain.
The standing objection. If I hold that nothing can be determined, do I not hold that this can be determined? The later sceptics answered that their own formulas are included in what they say: like a purgative drug that is expelled along with what it clears, or a ladder kicked away after the climb. They report how things strike them now and assert nothing about how things are.
Works
- Wrote nothing; known through fragments of Timon of Phlius, —
Where scholars disagree
Scholars disagree about whether Pyrrho made a claim about the nature of things (that they are indeterminate) or only about the limits of knowledge.
A common misreading
Stories that Pyrrho ignored cliffs and oncoming wagons and had to be saved by friends were told in antiquity as jokes against him. Other ancient sources say he lived sensibly, guided by appearances.
Influenced by
Influenced
Sextus Empiricus, Michel de Montaigne
Schools and eras
Pyrrhonian Scepticism, Hellenistic and Roman
Further reading
Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Open Pyrrho in the interactive Atlas, with lessons, quizzes, the map and the timeline.