Nicolas Malebranche
French priest and Cartesian who held that God is the only true cause and that we see all things in God.
Life
Malebranche was born in Paris, sickly and malformed, and entered the Oratory, a congregation of priests devoted to Augustine's theology. In 1664 he came upon a book by René Descartes in a bookshop and, it is said, read it with such excitement that he had to stop to calm his heart. The Search after Truth made him famous and involved him in long disputes with Arnauld, Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz and others.
Core ideas
- Occasionalism: created things have no causal power; God alone causes every event.
- What we call causes are occasions on which God acts by general laws.
- Vision in God: the ideas by which we perceive bodies are in God, not in us.
- We have no clear idea of our own soul, only an inner feeling of it.
- God acts by the simplest general laws, which is why the world contains evils.
In more depth
Occasionalism. Descartes had left the interaction of mind and body unexplained. Malebranche generalises the difficulty. A true cause is one between which and its effect the mind perceives a necessary connection. When one ball strikes another, I perceive no such connection; and my will to raise my arm does not explain how it rises, since I do not even know which nerves to move. The only necessary connection is between the will of an omnipotent being and its effect. So God moves the second ball on the occasion of the collision, and moves my arm on the occasion of my willing. David Hume kept the argument and dropped God.
Vision in God. How do we perceive bodies? Not directly, since the soul cannot go out to walk among the stars. By ideas. Malebranche reviews the possible sources of ideas: that bodies send them, that the soul makes them, that it was created with them all. He rejects each. God contains the ideas of all things he has created, and is intimately present to our minds. We therefore see bodies by seeing, in God, the idea of extension. Arnauld replied that ideas are simply acts of perceiving, and that this elaborate apparatus is unnecessary.
Why God permits evil. If God causes everything, why are there monsters, droughts and the damnation of sinners? Because wisdom requires him to act by a few simple and general laws, and such laws have by-products he does not will for themselves. Rain falls on the sea as well as on fields. He could prevent each evil only by particular acts unworthy of his wisdom. The argument shaped Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz's Theodicy and was mocked along with it.
Works
- The Search after Truth, 1674–1675
- Treatise on Nature and Grace, 1680
- Dialogues on Metaphysics and on Religion, 1688
Influenced by
René Descartes, Augustine of Hippo
Influenced
George Berkeley, David Hume, Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz
Schools and eras
Further reading
Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Open Nicolas Malebranche in the interactive Atlas, with lessons, quizzes, the map and the timeline.