H. L. A. Hart
English legal philosopher whose account of law as a system of rules is the leading modern statement of legal positivism.
Life
Hart was the son of a Jewish tailor in Yorkshire, read classics at Oxford, and practised for eight years as a barrister. During the war he worked for MI5, the British security service. He returned to Oxford to teach philosophy and in 1952 was elected to the chair of jurisprudence.
Core ideas
- Law is a union of primary rules, which impose duties, and secondary rules about how rules are made, changed and applied.
- A rule of recognition, accepted by officials, identifies what counts as law in a system.
- The existence of law is one thing; its merit or demerit is another.
- Rules have a core of settled meaning and a penumbra where judges must use discretion.
- The law should not enforce morality as such.
In more depth
The gunman. The older positivism of Bentham and the jurist John Austin defined law as the command of a sovereign backed by threats. Hart objects that this describes a gunman who orders a clerk to hand over money. The clerk is obliged to comply; he has no obligation. The theory also cannot explain laws that confer powers, such as those for making wills or contracts, or how law persists when one ruler succeeds another. What is missing is the idea of a rule, and of the internal point of view of those who accept it as a standard.
Primary and secondary rules. Imagine a society with only rules of duty. It would suffer three defects: uncertainty about what the rules are, no means of changing them, and no way of settling disputes. Each is cured by a secondary rule: a rule of recognition, rules of change, and rules of adjudication. Their union is the step from the pre-legal to the legal world. The rule of recognition is not itself valid or invalid. It exists as a practice of courts and officials.
No vehicles in the park. A rule forbids vehicles in the public park. It plainly covers a car. Does it cover a bicycle, roller skates, a toy car, an ambulance? Language has an open texture. In the penumbra a judge must choose, weighing the rule's purposes, and in doing so makes law. Hart steers between the formalist, who thinks rules settle everything, and the sceptic, who thinks they settle nothing.
Three debates. Against Lon Fuller, Hart held that a wicked Nazi statute was still law, and that clear thinking is served by saying “this is law, but too evil to obey”. Against Lord Devlin, who argued after the Wolfenden report that society may punish homosexual acts to preserve its moral fabric, he defended Mill's harm principle. His student Ronald Dworkin argued that law contains principles as well as rules; Hart's reply appeared in a postscript after his death.
Works
- Positivism and the Separation of Law and Morals, 1958
- The Concept of Law, 1961
- Law, Liberty, and Morality, 1963
- Punishment and Responsibility, 1968
Influenced by
Jeremy Bentham, Ludwig Wittgenstein, John Stuart Mill
Influenced
Related ideas
Schools and eras
Further reading
Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Open H. L. A. Hart in the interactive Atlas, with lessons, quizzes, the map and the timeline.