Ronald Dworkin
American legal and political philosopher who held that law includes moral principles and that rights are trumps.
Life
Dworkin studied at Harvard and Oxford, clerked for the judge Learned Hand, and practised briefly on Wall Street. He succeeded H. L. A. Hart in the Oxford chair of jurisprudence in 1969 and later divided his time between London and New York University. For decades he wrote on Supreme Court decisions for a general readership.
Core ideas
- Law consists of principles as well as rules, and principles have weight.
- Hard cases have right answers, found by the best moral interpretation of the legal record.
- Rights are trumps that individuals hold against goals of the community.
- Government must treat those it governs with equal concern and respect.
- A just distribution is sensitive to people's choices and insensitive to their unchosen circumstances.
In more depth
Riggs v. Palmer. In 1889 a New York court had to decide whether a young man who had murdered his grandfather could inherit under the grandfather's will. The statute of wills, read literally, gave him the property. The court refused, citing the principle that no one should profit from his own wrong. Dworkin uses the case against H. L. A. Hart. The principle was not enacted by anyone and passes no test of pedigree, yet the judges treated it as binding law. Rules apply in an all-or-nothing way; principles incline a decision one way and must be weighed.
Hercules and the chain novel. Dworkin imagines a judge of superhuman skill, Hercules, who decides a hard case by constructing the theory that best fits and best justifies the whole body of past decisions. Judging is like writing the next chapter of a novel written by many hands: the judge must continue the story so as to make it the best it can be, and is constrained by what has gone before. This is law as integrity. It implies that judges do not have discretion in Hart's sense: even in hard cases a party has a right to win.
Trumps. Most political decisions are justified by the general welfare. A right is a claim that holds even when overriding it would serve that welfare. Rights follow from the more basic requirement of equal concern and respect. On this basis Dworkin defended free speech, the right to privacy in abortion and sexuality, and affirmative action, which he argued violates no one's right to be treated as an equal.
Insurance and the hedgehog. To make equality concrete he imagines shipwrecked survivors who divide an island's resources by auction with equal stakes, so that no one envies another's bundle. Since people differ in luck, they are then offered insurance against handicap and lack of talent, on equal terms; taxation should mimic the cover people would have bought. His last major book argues that ethical and moral values form a single unified whole, against Isaiah Berlin's pluralism.
Works
- Taking Rights Seriously, 1977
- A Matter of Principle, 1985
- Law's Empire, 1986
- Sovereign Virtue, 2000
- Justice for Hedgehogs, 2011
Influenced by
H. L. A. Hart, John Rawls, Immanuel Kant, John Stuart Mill
Schools and eras
Further reading
Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Open Ronald Dworkin in the interactive Atlas, with lessons, quizzes, the map and the timeline.