Anaxagoras
Presocratic philosopher who brought natural philosophy to Athens and introduced Mind as the cause of cosmic order.
Life
Anaxagoras came from Clazomenae on the coast of Asia Minor and lived for some thirty years in Athens, where he was a friend of Pericles. He was prosecuted for impiety, by one account for saying that the sun is a fiery stone, and left for Lampsacus, where he died honoured. A single book of his was on sale in Athens for a drachma, Socrates says in Plato's Apology.
Core ideas
- Nothing comes to be or perishes; there is only mixture and separation.
- In everything there is a portion of everything.
- Matter is infinitely divisible: there is no smallest part.
- Mind (nous) is unmixed, knows all things, and set the original mixture rotating.
- The sun, moon and stars are fiery stones, and the moon shines by reflected light.
In more depth
Everything in everything. Anaxagoras accepts from Parmenides that nothing can come from what is not. How then does bread become flesh, bone and hair when we eat it? Hair cannot come from what is not hair. So bread must already contain portions of flesh, bone and hair, too small to see. Generalising: in everything there is a portion of everything. A thing is called by what predominates in it. Gold is what has mostly gold. There is no smallest quantity, so however far one divides, every ingredient is still present.
Mind. In the beginning all things were together, an indistinguishable mixture. Mind, which alone is mixed with nothing, is the finest and purest of things, has all knowledge and the greatest strength. It began a rotation in a small region, and the rotation spread, separating dense from rare, hot from cold, and forming the world. Mind controls all things that have soul. This is the first clear separation of an ordering intelligence from the matter it orders.
Socrates' disappointment. In Plato's Phaedo, Socrates tells how as a young man he heard that Anaxagoras made Mind the cause of everything, and bought the book with high hopes. He expected to learn why it is best that things are as they are. He found a man who made no use of Mind and gave as causes air, ether and water. It was as if one explained why Socrates sits in prison by his bones and sinews and not by his decision that it was right to stay. Aristotle made the same complaint: Mind is wheeled in like a stage device when other explanations fail.
The astronomer. Anaxagoras gave the correct explanation of eclipses, and held that the moon has plains and ravines. He is said to have predicted the fall of a meteorite. Asked what made life worth living, he answered: to study the heavens and the order of the whole cosmos.
Works
- On Nature, c. 470–460 BCE; fragments only
Influenced by
Influenced
Socrates, Plato, Aristotle, Democritus
Schools and eras
Further reading
Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Open Anaxagoras in the interactive Atlas, with lessons, quizzes, the map and the timeline.