Friedrich Wilhelm Joseph Schelling
German idealist who gave nature a standing equal to mind and later criticised purely rational philosophy.
Life
Schelling entered the Tübingen seminary at fifteen and shared rooms with G.W.F. Hegel and the poet Hölderlin. He was a professor at Jena at twenty-three, at the centre of the Romantic circle. His thought passed through many phases. After Hegel's death he was called to Berlin in 1841 to counter Hegel's influence; his audience included Søren Kierkegaard, Engels and Bakunin.
Core ideas
- Nature is visible mind, and mind is invisible nature.
- Nature is productive activity, not a collection of dead objects.
- Art reveals the unity of the conscious and the unconscious that philosophy can only describe.
- Freedom is the capacity for good and for evil, and has its root in a dark ground in God.
- Reason can tell what things are, but not that anything exists.
In more depth
Philosophy of nature. For Johann Gottlieb Fichte nature was only the not-I, the material of duty. Schelling objected that mind could not have arisen from a nature wholly alien to it. Nature must be understood as a process that produces ever more organised forms, magnetism, electricity, chemical action, life, and finally consciousness, in which it comes to know itself. The objects we see are arrested moments of this productivity, like eddies in a stream. The view influenced the science of his day and fell into disrepute for its speculation.
Art. The System of Transcendental Idealism traces the history of consciousness from sensation to free action and ends with art. In the work of art, conscious intention and unconscious inspiration are one: the artist puts in more than he knows. Art therefore shows outwardly what philosophy seeks, the identity of the subjective and objective. He called art the organ and document of philosophy. Hegel later mocked the philosophy of identity that followed as a night in which all cows are black.
The freedom essay. If God is all, where does evil come from? Schelling denies that evil is mere lack. Freedom is real only if it is freedom for evil. He distinguishes in God his existence from the ground of his existence, a dark longing that is in God but is not God. In creatures the two can separate: self-will can raise itself above the universal will. Evil is a positive perversion, like disease in an organism.
Positive philosophy. In his late lectures he argued that Hegel's system is negative philosophy: it unfolds what must be thought if anything is, and cannot reach actual existence. That there is something and not nothing is a fact for which no reason can be deduced. Philosophy must begin again from this, and attend to history, mythology and revelation. Kierkegaard was disappointed by the lectures, but the criticism of Hegel is the beginning of existential thought.
Works
- Ideas for a Philosophy of Nature, 1797
- System of Transcendental Idealism, 1800
- Philosophical Investigations into the Essence of Human Freedom, 1809
- The Ages of the World, drafts 1811–1815
Influenced by
Immanuel Kant, Johann Gottlieb Fichte, Baruch Spinoza, Plato
Influenced
G.W.F. Hegel, Søren Kierkegaard, Martin Heidegger
Schools and eras
Further reading
Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Open Friedrich Wilhelm Joseph Schelling in the interactive Atlas, with lessons, quizzes, the map and the timeline.