Karl Popper
Philosopher of science who made falsifiability the mark of scientific theories and defended the “open society” against its enemies.
Life
Popper grew up in Vienna, trained as a teacher and took a doctorate in psychology. He knew members of the Vienna Circle but was never one of them, and his first book criticised their views. Being of Jewish descent, he left Austria in 1937 for a post in New Zealand.
There he wrote The Open Society and Its Enemies, his “war effort”. From 1946 he taught at the London School of Economics, where he remained until retirement.
Core ideas
- Falsifiability: a theory is scientific only if it could be refuted by some possible observation.
- Science advances by bold conjectures and attempts to refute them, not by induction.
- Theories can be corroborated but never verified.
- Historicism, the belief in laws of historical destiny, is unscientific and politically dangerous.
- An open society reforms itself by piecemeal change and allows rulers to be removed without bloodshed.
In more depth
Demarcation. Popper asked what distinguishes science from pseudo-science. He was struck by the contrast between Einstein's theory, which made a risky prediction that the eclipse observations of 1919 might have refuted, and the theories of Freud, Adler and the Marxism of his day, which seemed able to explain any outcome. His answer: a theory is scientific if it is falsifiable, if it forbids certain observable events. The criterion separates science from non-science, not sense from nonsense.
Against induction. Hume was right that no number of observations can justify a universal law. But science does not need induction. A universal statement cannot be verified, yet it can be refuted by a single counter-instance. Science proceeds by bold conjectures and severe attempts to refute them. A theory that survives is corroborated, which is a report on its past performance and not a probability of its truth.
Method. Since a theory can always be saved from refutation by adjusting other assumptions, falsifiability is a matter of method. Scientists must decide in advance not to protect their theories by ad hoc manoeuvres. Observation statements are themselves accepted by convention and remain open to test. Critics, including Kuhn and Lakatos, argued that real science does not and should not abandon theories at the first failure.
Truth and knowledge. He held a realist view: science aims at truth and makes progress by getting nearer to it, though his formal definition of nearness to truth was shown to fail. Knowledge exists objectively, in theories and arguments, apart from anyone's beliefs.
The open society. The same attitude applies to politics. Since no one knows the good society, institutions should allow rulers to be removed without bloodshed and policies to be corrected. He attacked historicism, the claim that history has laws permitting prophecy, and traced it through Plato, Hegel and Marx. Reform should be piecemeal, aimed at removing identifiable evils.
Vienna and exile. Popper grew up in Vienna, worked for a time as a cabinetmaker's apprentice and with the psychologist Alfred Adler, and became a schoolteacher. He was close to the Vienna Circle and never a member, and regarded himself as the critic who killed logical positivism. Of Jewish descent, he left Austria in 1937 for New Zealand, where he wrote The Open Society as his contribution to the war, and after 1946 taught at the London School of Economics.
Corroboration. A theory that survives severe tests is corroborated. This is a report on past performance only. It gives no ground for thinking the theory true or probably true. Popper holds that the better theories are the more improbable ones, since they say more and forbid more. Critics ask why, if corroboration says nothing about the future, it is rational to build a bridge using a well-tested theory. This is the chief objection to his solution of the problem of induction.
Three worlds. Popper distinguishes the world of physical things, the world of mental states, and a third world of the products of the human mind considered in themselves: theories, problems, arguments. Once stated, a theory has consequences its author did not foresee and that are there to be discovered. Knowledge in this objective sense exists in libraries and does not need a knowing subject.
Piecemeal engineering. Against the planning of whole societies according to a blueprint, Popper recommends small reforms aimed at particular evils, each treated as an experiment whose results can be checked. Aim at reducing suffering and not at producing happiness. The paradox of tolerance is his: a tolerant society must be prepared to defend itself against the intolerant, or tolerance will be destroyed.
The poker. In 1946 Popper read a paper at Cambridge with Wittgenstein in the chair. They disagreed over whether there are real philosophical problems or only puzzles. Accounts differ, but Wittgenstein, who had been gesturing with a fireplace poker, left the room; Popper said he had offered “not to threaten visiting lecturers with pokers” as an example of a moral rule.
Works
- The Logic of Scientific Discovery, published late 1934, dated 1935; English edition 1959
- The Open Society and Its Enemies, 1945
- The Poverty of Historicism, 1957
- Conjectures and Refutations, 1963
A common misreading
Popper was not a logical positivist. He offered falsifiability as a criterion of what is scientific, not of what is meaningful, and he held that metaphysical ideas can be meaningful and fruitful.
Influenced by
David Hume, Immanuel Kant, Rudolf Carnap, Bertrand Russell
Influenced
Related ideas
Schools and eras
Further reading
Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Open Karl Popper in the interactive Atlas, with lessons, quizzes, the map and the timeline.