Mozi
Founder of Mohism, who argued for impartial concern for all and judged policies by their benefit to the people.
Life
Little is known of Mozi's life. He was probably of humble, perhaps artisan, origin, and was active in the fifth century BCE, after Confucius and before Mencius. He founded a disciplined organisation of followers who lived frugally and were known for their skill in defensive warfare, which they offered to small states under attack.
The book that carries his name was compiled by his followers over a long period. It contains the first sustained philosophical arguments in Chinese literature, along with later chapters on logic, optics and mechanics.
Core ideas
- Impartial care (jian ai): one should care for other people's families and states as for one's own.
- Policies are to be judged by whether they bring wealth, population and order to the world.
- Offensive war is the greatest of crimes.
- Elaborate funerals, prolonged mourning and costly music waste resources the people need.
- Doctrines must be tested by three standards: precedent, the evidence of people's eyes and ears, and practical benefit.
In more depth
Three tests. Mozi is the first Chinese thinker to argue explicitly for criteria of judgement. A doctrine must be tested by its basis in the practice of the ancient sage kings, by its confirmation in what people have seen and heard, and by its usefulness: whether, applied in government, it benefits the state and the people. The third does most of the work.
Impartial care. The great harms of the world, war between states, strife between clans, robbery, arise from partiality: people care for their own and not for others. The remedy is that everyone regard the states, families and persons of others as their own. Mozi argues that this benefits everyone, and that even those who object in words would in practice entrust their family to an impartial person and not a partial one.
The Confucian reply. Mencius charged that to care for all impartially is to deny one's father. The Mohists answered that impartial care, if practised by all, serves one's parents better, since others will care for them too. The debate turns on whether special obligations are basic or derived.
Against waste and war. Elaborate funerals, three years of mourning and court music consume wealth and labour that could feed and clothe people. They are condemned by the test of benefit. Offensive war is the greatest injustice. If killing one man is a crime, how can killing thousands be called right? The Mohists were experts in defensive warfare and went to the aid of threatened cities.
Heaven and order. Heaven wants righteousness, rewards those who benefit others and punishes those who harm them, and so is the standard, like a carpenter's compass. Spirits enforce it. Disorder arises when each has his own view of what is right; order requires that all conform their judgements upward to their superiors and finally to Heaven. He rejected belief in fate as an excuse for idleness and held that office should go to the worthy regardless of birth.
The later Mohists. His successors produced the most developed logic, optics and mechanics of ancient China. The school vanished after the Qin unification and was recovered only in modern times.
The movement. Mozi's name suggests a craftsman's origin, and his followers formed a disciplined organisation under a leader, skilled in building fortifications and defending besieged cities. One story tells how he walked for ten days to dissuade the king of Chu from attacking a small state, and defeated the engineer Gongshu Ban in a tabletop contest of siege and defence. The school was the main rival of the Confucians for two centuries and then disappeared; the text was recovered by scholars only in the Qing dynasty.
The form of the argument. The core chapters each defend one of ten doctrines and survive in up to three versions. They proceed by stating a thesis, giving reasons, answering objections and repeating the conclusion. This is the first sustained argumentative prose in China. Mozi demands a standard, as a wheelwright has his compass and a carpenter his square: without a model, he says, arguing is like trying to tell east from west on a spinning potter's wheel.
The thought experiment for impartial care. Suppose you must go on a long campaign and entrust your parents, wife and children to someone. Would you choose a man who cares for others as for himself, or one who cares only for his own? Even those who reject impartial care in words would choose the impartial man. So people condemn the doctrine with their mouths and prefer it in their choices. The argument tests a moral view by what its opponents would rely on.
Against fatalism and for conformity upward. Mozi attacks the belief in fate because it makes people idle: if wealth and poverty are fixed, why work? He also argues that disorder comes from each person having his own view of what is right. The remedy is that each level of society should identify its standards with those of the level above, up to the Son of Heaven, who conforms to Heaven. Critics see in this a recipe for authoritarian rule.
Promoting the worthy. Office should go to the capable, whatever their birth, even to farmers and artisans; rank, salary and authority should follow merit. This was a challenge to hereditary aristocracy, and it later became a commonplace of Chinese political thought.
Works
- Mozi, compiled by followers, c. 5th–3rd century BCE
A common misreading
Jian ai is often translated “universal love”, which suggests an emotion. The doctrine concerns impartial concern in conduct and policy, and many scholars prefer “impartial care” or “inclusive care”.
Influenced by
Influenced
Related ideas
Schools and eras
Further reading
Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Open Mozi in the interactive Atlas, with lessons, quizzes, the map and the timeline.