Atlas of Philosophy

All entries › Philosophers

Xunzi

c. 310 BCE – c. 235 BCE · State of Zhao; Qi and Chu, China · Chinese

Confucian philosopher who held that human nature is bad and that goodness is the product of ritual, teaching and deliberate effort.

Also known as: Xun Kuang, Hsün Tzu, 荀子

Life

Xunzi was born in the state of Zhao and became the most eminent scholar at the Jixia academy in Qi, a gathering place for thinkers of every school. He later served as a magistrate at Lanling in the state of Chu, where he died.

Unlike earlier Chinese texts, his book consists largely of sustained essays on set topics. Tradition names Han Feizi and the Qin minister Li Si among his students, which later damaged his standing among Confucians.

Core ideas

In more depth

Human nature is bad. Against Mencius, Xunzi argues that people are born with a love of profit, with envy and with desires of ear and eye. If these are followed, strife and disorder result. Goodness is the product of conscious activity, wei, a word that can also mean artifice. Crooked wood must be steamed and bent to become straight, and blunt metal ground to become sharp.

Why the difference matters. For Mencius cultivation develops what is already there. For Xunzi it reshapes raw material by means of something from outside: teachers, models and ritual. Yet he holds that anyone can become a sage, since all have the capacity to understand and practise what is right. The disagreement is about the starting point and the method, not about the goal.

Ritual. Where does ritual come from? Human desires are without limit and goods are scarce. The ancient sage kings, hating the resulting disorder, established ritual and rightness to set bounds, so that desires and goods could support each other. Ritual thus has a human origin and a social function: it nourishes desire, marks distinctions of rank and gives form to feeling, as in mourning.

Heaven. Heaven's course is constant. It does not exist for a sage king or cease for a tyrant. Eclipses and falling stars are rare natural events, to be wondered at and not feared. One prays for rain and it rains, and it would have rained anyway. The ceremonies are valuable as culture, and only the common people take them as dealing with spirits. Human beings should attend to their own task of ordering the world.

Mind and names. The mind can be obsessed by one aspect of things and blind to the rest. It knows the Way by being empty, unified and still. Names are fixed by convention, and when they are confused, argument and government break down.

Legacy. His students Han Fei and Li Si became the leading Legalists, which damaged his reputation. He was passed over when Mencius was canonised, though his influence on Han Confucianism was great.

The man and the book. Xunzi lived in the third century BCE, taught at the Jixia academy in Qi, where scholars of all schools gathered, and ended as a magistrate in Chu. He visited Qin and admired its order while noting its lack of learning. His book consists of sustained essays on single topics, such as learning, ritual, music, Heaven and names, and is the most systematic work of early Confucianism.

Learning. The first essay begins: learning must never stop. Blue dye comes from the indigo plant and is bluer than the plant. Wood as straight as a plumb line can be steamed and bent into a wheel, and it will not straighten again. A gentleman who studies widely and examines himself daily becomes clear in understanding and faultless in conduct. Learning begins with reciting the classics and ends with ritual; its purpose is to become a sage. It needs a teacher and persistence, as a slow horse covers the distance by not giving up.

Where ritual comes from. People are born with desires. Unsatisfied, they seek; seeking without limit, they contend; contention brings disorder and poverty. The ancient kings hated this disorder and established ritual and rightness to apportion things, to train desires and supply what is sought, so that desires would not exhaust goods and goods would not fall short of desires. Ritual does not suppress feeling. It gives grief, joy and respect a fitting form, as in mourning, which is neither cut short nor allowed to destroy the living.

Dispelling obsession. The mind goes wrong by being fixed on one corner of the truth: Mozi was blinded by utility and did not understand culture; Zhuangzi was blinded by Heaven and did not understand man. The remedy is a mind that is empty, unified and still. Empty: what it already holds does not block what it is about to receive. Unified: it can attend to one thing without confusion. Still: it is not disturbed by dreams and fancies. Such a mind is like a pan of water in which sediment has settled.

Music and the response to Mozi. Music is joy, a thing human feeling cannot do without. Mozi condemned it as waste. Xunzi replies that sounds enter deeply and transform people quickly; right music makes a people harmonious, and the kings regulated it for that reason. His confidence that institutions shape character runs through the whole book.

Works

A common misreading

“Human nature is bad” does not mean that people are wicked by design or beyond improvement. Xunzi held that anyone can become a sage through effort; his point is that goodness is acquired and not inborn.

Influenced by

Confucius, Mencius, Mozi

Influenced

Han Feizi

Schools and eras

Confucianism, Classical Chinese

Further reading

Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy

Open Xunzi in the interactive Atlas, with lessons, quizzes, the map and the timeline.

This page is part of the philosophers list. How this content was made, and its limits, are described in the Terms of use.