Mencius
The most influential early follower of Confucius, who held that human nature is good and that government must rest on the people's welfare.
Life
Mencius was born in the small state of Zou, near Confucius's home state of Lu, and is said to have studied under followers of Confucius's grandson. Like Confucius he travelled from court to court, advising the rulers of Qi, Liang and other states, without lasting success.
The book named after him records his conversations with kings and rivals. In the twelfth century Zhu Xi made it one of the Four Books, the core of Confucian education until the twentieth century.
Core ideas
- Human nature is good: everyone has four “sprouts” (compassion, shame, deference, and a sense of right and wrong) that grow into the virtues if nurtured.
- Anyone who suddenly saw a child about to fall into a well would feel alarm and compassion (Mencius 2A6).
- A true king wins the people by humane government; one who relies on force is a mere hegemon.
- The people matter most, the state next, the ruler least (7B14).
- A ruler who ruins humaneness and rightness is a mere “fellow”, and removing him is not regicide (1B8).
In more depth
Human nature is good. Mencius defends Confucius against rival schools by arguing that the capacity for virtue is inborn. His evidence is a case. Anyone who suddenly saw a child about to fall into a well would feel alarm and compassion, and not in order to win favour with the parents or praise from neighbours. From this he concludes that all people have a heart that cannot bear the suffering of others.
The four sprouts. The feeling of compassion is the sprout of humaneness; the feeling of shame, of rightness; the feeling of deference, of ritual propriety; the sense of right and wrong, of wisdom. People have these four as they have four limbs. They are beginnings, and must be nourished to become full virtues.
Why people go wrong. If nature is good, where does evil come from? From neglect and bad conditions. Ox Mountain was once wooded, but axes and grazing herds stripped it bare, and people now think it never had trees. In the same way a person's nature is cut down day after day. Cultivation must not be forced: a farmer who pulled at his shoots to help them grow killed them.
The debate with Gaozi. Gaozi held that human nature is neutral, like water that will flow east or west as a channel is opened. Mencius replied that water has no preference for east or west but does tend downward, and human nature tends toward good in the same way.
Government. A ruler should practise humane government: light taxes, fair distribution of land, care for the old and orphaned. People without a secure livelihood cannot be expected to have steady hearts. The people are the most important, the altars of soil and grain next, the ruler last. A tyrant has lost the standing of a king, so that the killing of the tyrant Zhou was the punishment of a mere fellow and not regicide.
Later standing. Xunzi attacked the doctrine of good nature. A thousand years later the Neo-Confucians made the Mencius one of the Four Books, and it became orthodox.
The book and the man. Mencius lived in the fourth century BCE and travelled from court to court offering advice that rulers praised and did not take. The book that bears his name, unlike the Analects, contains long conversations and arguments. It opens with King Hui of Liang asking what he has brought to profit the state, and Mencius replying: why must the king speak of profit? There is humaneness and rightness, and that is all.
The ox. King Xuan of Qi once saw an ox being led to sacrifice and, unable to bear its frightened look, ordered a sheep to be used instead. Mencius tells him that this feeling is enough to make a true king. He was able to pity the ox because he saw it; he had not seen the sheep. The task is to extend the same feeling to his people, whom he also does not see. Moral development is the extension of responses one already has.
The man from Song. A farmer in Song, worried that his grain was not growing, pulled at each shoot to help it along, and came home saying he was worn out. His son ran to the field and found the plants withered. There are few who do not help the grain grow in this way. Some neglect it and do not weed; others pull at it. Moral cultivation needs steady attention and cannot be forced. Mencius speaks of nourishing a flood-like vital energy through accumulated right action.
Ox Mountain. The trees on Ox Mountain were once beautiful. Being on the edge of a great city, they were cut down by axes, and when shoots sprang up cattle and sheep grazed them away. People see it bare and suppose it never had trees. Is this the nature of the mountain? So with a person whose good heart is hacked at day after day. The parable answers the objection that people are evidently not good.
Fish and bear's paw. I like fish and I like bear's paw; if I cannot have both, I take the bear's paw. I want life and I want rightness; if I cannot have both, I choose rightness. A starving beggar will refuse food that is offered with a kick. A ruler who outrages humaneness and rightness is a mere fellow, and Mencius says he has heard of the execution of the fellow Zhou, not of the murder of a king.
Works
- Mencius (Mengzi), compiled c. late 4th century BCE
A common misreading
Mencius did not claim that people are born fully virtuous. His image is agricultural: we are born with sprouts of goodness that can flourish or be destroyed by neglect and a bad environment.
Influenced by
Influenced
Schools and eras
Confucianism, Classical Chinese
Further reading
Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Open Mencius in the interactive Atlas, with lessons, quizzes, the map and the timeline.