Han Feizi
The great synthesiser of Legalism, who taught that states are made strong by impartial law, administrative technique and the ruler's position of power.
Life
Han Fei was a member of the ruling family of the small state of Han. According to Sima Qian he stuttered and so wrote instead of speaking, and studied under Xunzi. His essays failed to move his own ruler but impressed the king of Qin, the future First Emperor.
Sent to Qin as an envoy in 233 BCE, he was imprisoned there through the intrigue of his former fellow student Li Si, and died after being made to take poison. Qin unified China twelve years later, on principles close to his.
Core ideas
- Law (fa): clear, public rules applied to everyone alike, backed by generous rewards and severe punishments.
- Technique (shu): the ruler's methods for controlling officials, above all checking that their performance matches their titles and claims.
- Positional power (shi): authority belongs to the throne, not to the personal virtue of whoever sits on it.
- People act from self-interest, so government should be designed for ordinary rulers and ordinary subjects, not for sages.
- Methods that suited antiquity do not suit the present.
In more depth
The premise. Han Fei starts from the claim that people act from calculation of their own advantage. A carriage maker hopes men will grow rich, a coffin maker that they will die. Neither is kind or cruel. Even parents, he observes, treat sons and daughters differently for reasons of interest. A ruler who relies on the goodness of his subjects will find very few to rely on.
Against the past. The Confucians urge rulers to imitate the sage kings. Han Fei answers with the story of a farmer who saw a rabbit run into a stump and break its neck, and then sat by the stump waiting for another. Conditions change. When people were few and goods plentiful, generosity was easy. The methods that suited antiquity do not suit a crowded and competitive age.
Law. Laws must be written, public and applied alike to high and low. Rewards should be generous and certain, punishments heavy and unavoidable. These are the two handles by which the ruler controls his ministers. With clear law, an ordinary ruler can govern well; the state should not depend on waiting for a sage.
Technique. The ruler needs methods for managing officials. Each minister states what he will do, and is then judged by whether the result matches the proposal. To achieve less is punished, and so is achieving more, since the mismatch itself is the fault. The ruler must not reveal his likes and dislikes, or ministers will shape themselves to them.
Position. Even a worthy man cannot command without power, and a mediocre man with authority is obeyed. The ruler's strength lies in his position, which he must never share. Han Fei draws these three strands from earlier thinkers and joins them.
The Daoist element. He interprets Laozi's non-action as the stance of a ruler who stays still and empty while the machinery of law and office runs. Critics ancient and modern have judged the system a recipe for tyranny, and the dynasty that used it fell within fifteen years.
The life. Han Fei was a prince of the small state of Han and, by tradition, a stammerer who wrote because he could not speak persuasively. He studied under Xunzi. His essays reached the king of Qin, the future First Emperor, who is said to have exclaimed that he would die content if he could meet their author. When Han Fei came to Qin as an envoy, his former fellow student Li Si, now a minister, had him imprisoned, and he died there in 233 BCE, reportedly by poison sent by Li Si.
The stump and the hare. A farmer of Song saw a hare run into a tree stump and break its neck. He put down his plough and waited by the stump for another. No more hares came, and he became the laughing-stock of Song. Those who wish to govern the people of today by the policies of the former kings are all watchers of the stump. In antiquity people were few and goods plentiful, so they did not contend; now it is the reverse. Circumstances change, and measures must change with them.
Spear and shield. A man of Chu sold spears and shields. He praised his shields as so hard nothing could pierce them, and his spears as so sharp there was nothing they could not pierce. Someone asked: what if your spear is used on your shield? He could not answer. The Chinese word for contradiction is literally “spear-shield”, from this story. Han Fei used it against the Confucians, who praised both the sage Yao and the sage Shun who reformed the people under Yao's rule.
The two handles. The ruler controls his ministers by two handles, punishment and favour, and must never let them out of his hands. He should also hold names to results. A minister states what he will do; the ruler assigns the task and compares the outcome with the words. If the result falls short, the minister is punished; if it exceeds, he is punished too, since the mismatch matters more than the gain. A marquis once punished both the keeper of the robe and the keeper of the hat when the second covered him as he slept.
The difficulty of persuasion. One essay analyses the dangers of advising a ruler: the difficulty is not in knowing what to say but in knowing the heart of the person addressed. Beneath the dragon's throat are reversed scales, and whoever touches them dies. The essay is poignant given its author's end.
Works
- Han Feizi, c. mid-3rd century BCE
A common misreading
Han Fei did not call himself a Legalist. The category fa jia, “school of law”, was devised by Han dynasty historians about a century after his death.
Influenced by
Schools and eras
Further reading
Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Open Han Feizi in the interactive Atlas, with lessons, quizzes, the map and the timeline.