Atlas of Philosophy

All entries › Ideas

Impartial care

The Mohist doctrine that one should be concerned for everyone's welfare equally, without favouring one's own family or state.

Also known as: Jian ai, Universal love, Inclusive care, 兼愛

Explanation

Mozi asked what causes the great harms of the world: war between states, feuds between families, theft and oppression. His answer is partiality. People care for their own state, family and person and not for those of others. The remedy is to regard other states as one's own, other families as one's own, and other persons as oneself.

He argues for it by its results. If everyone practised it, there would be no aggression, and the old and orphaned would be provided for. He adds a thought experiment: when leaving for war and entrusting your family to someone, would you choose a partial person or an impartial one? Even opponents of the doctrine, he says, would choose the impartial one.

Critics

Mencius replied that to love all equally is to deny one's own father, and that natural affection has a single root in the family. Later Mohists appear to have allowed special duties to kin within an impartial framework.

Mencius, Xunzi

Where scholars disagree

Scholars disagree about whether the doctrine demands equal feeling for everyone, equal treatment, or only that everyone's welfare be included in one's concern.

Originator

Mozi

Related ideas

Ren, Principle of utility

Schools

Mohism

Further reading

Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy

Open Impartial care in the interactive Atlas, with lessons, quizzes, the map and the timeline.

This page is part of the ideas list. How this content was made, and its limits, are described in the Terms of use.