Atlas of Philosophy

All entries › Philosophers

al-Ghazali

c. 1058 CE – 1111 CE · Tus, Iran; Baghdad · Islamic

Theologian, jurist and mystic who subjected the philosophers to a searching critique and gave Sufism a secure place in Sunni Islam.

Also known as: Abu Hamid al-Ghazali, Algazel

Life

Al-Ghazali was born at Tus in north-eastern Iran and became the leading professor at the Nizamiyya college in Baghdad in 1091. In 1095, by his own account, a spiritual crisis left him unable to teach. He gave up his post and spent about a decade in retirement and travel, living as a Sufi.

He later returned to teaching for a short time and died in his home town. His autobiography, Deliverance from Error, describes his search for certainty through theology, philosophy and mysticism.

Core ideas

In more depth

The crisis and the method. In his autobiography al-Ghazali describes doubting first the senses and then reason itself, until certainty was restored by a light cast into his heart and not by argument. He then examined the four groups of seekers after truth: theologians, philosophers, those who followed an infallible imam, and the Sufis. He concluded that the Sufi path of direct experience goes furthest.

The Incoherence. He first wrote an accurate summary of the philosophers' doctrines and then attacked twenty of them, using the philosophers' own logic. His claim is that they have failed to demonstrate what they assert. Seventeen theses are innovations. Three amount to unbelief: that the world is eternal, that God knows only universals and not particulars, and that there is no bodily resurrection.

Causation. The seventeenth discussion argues that the connection between what is habitually taken to be a cause and its effect is not necessary. Fire touches cotton and the cotton burns, but observation shows only that the burning occurs with the contact, not that it occurs through it. There is no contradiction in the one without the other. The real agent is God, who creates events in a customary sequence and can depart from it in a miracle. The resemblance to Hume's later analysis is often noted; al-Ghazali's purpose, to safeguard divine power, is different.

Not an enemy of logic. He insisted that logic and mathematics are religiously neutral and should be learned, and he brought Aristotelian logic into Islamic theology and law. Much of his own metaphysics draws on Ibn Sina. The older picture of him as having ended philosophy in Islam is no longer accepted by historians.

The Revival. His largest work reorders the religious sciences around the purification of the heart, joining law, theology and Sufi practice.

The stages of doubt. In the Deliverer from Error al-Ghazali describes losing confidence in everything he had been taught. Sense perception fails: a shadow looks still and is moving; a star looks the size of a coin. Reason corrects the senses, but perhaps a higher judge would correct reason, as waking corrects a dream. For two months he was a sceptic in fact though not in speech. The cure came, he says, not by proof but by a light that God cast into his breast.

Leaving Baghdad. In 1095, at the height of his fame as professor at the Nizamiyya college, he found himself unable to speak in the lecture hall. He concluded that he had been teaching for the sake of reputation. He left his post, made provision for his family, and spent about eleven years in retreat and travel, in Damascus, Jerusalem and Mecca, before returning to teach in his home region. The Revival of the Religious Sciences was written in these years.

The balance of the heart. The Revival is in four quarters: acts of worship, the customs of daily life, the vices that destroy, and the virtues that save. Its concern is the inner state that should accompany each outward act. Knowledge is of two kinds, that which concerns conduct and that which is unveiling; the book treats only the first and points toward the second. Certainty about God, he says, comes by tasting, as one knows drunkenness by being drunk and not by its definition.

The Niche of Lights. A late work interprets the Qur'an's Light Verse. God alone is light in the true sense; everything else is light only by borrowing. Its final section ranks those veiled from God, and some passages come close to the philosophers' cosmology he had attacked. Readers from Ibn Rushd onward have asked whether al-Ghazali held one doctrine for the public and another for the few. The question remains open.

Works

Where scholars disagree

Scholars disagree about whether al-Ghazali was a thoroughgoing occasionalist or allowed for real secondary causes.

A common misreading

Al-Ghazali is often blamed for ending philosophy and science in the Islamic world. Historians now largely reject this. Philosophy continued for centuries after him, and he himself helped bring Aristotelian logic into theology.

Influenced by

Ibn Sina (Avicenna), al-Farabi

Influenced

Ibn Rushd (Averroes), Moses Maimonides

Schools and eras

Ash‘arite Kalam, Islamic Golden Age

Further reading

Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy

Open al-Ghazali in the interactive Atlas, with lessons, quizzes, the map and the timeline.

This page is part of the philosophers list. How this content was made, and its limits, are described in the Terms of use.