Gorgias
Sicilian sophist and teacher of rhetoric who argued that nothing exists, and that speech is a mighty lord.
Life
Gorgias came to Athens in 427 BCE as an ambassador from Leontini and astonished the assembly with his style, full of balanced clauses and rhymes. He travelled the Greek cities giving display speeches and teaching for high fees, and is said to have lived past a hundred. Plato named a dialogue after him, in which rhetoric is attacked as a form of flattery.
Core ideas
- Nothing exists; if it did, it could not be known; if it were known, it could not be communicated.
- Speech is a powerful ruler that works on the soul as drugs work on the body.
- Persuasion can make anything seem so, since most people have only opinion.
- Rhetoric is a neutral skill, and the teacher is not to blame if a pupil misuses it.
- Tragedy is a deception in which the deceiver is more just than the non-deceiver.
In more depth
Three theses. On Not-Being argues, first, that nothing exists. If something existed it would be either eternal or generated, one or many, and each option is refuted with arguments in the Eleatic manner. Second, even if something existed, it could not be known, since if things thought of existed, then chariots racing on the sea would exist whenever someone thought of them. Third, even if it could be known, it could not be told to another, because what we convey is speech, and speech is not the thing. Whether this is a parody of Parmenides, a serious scepticism, or a display of what argument can do, has always been disputed.
Helen. The Encomium defends Helen of Troy. She went with Paris for one of four reasons: the will of the gods, physical force, persuasion by speech, or love. In no case is she to blame. The section on speech is the heart of it. Speech is a mighty lord, which with the smallest and least visible body achieves the most divine works: it can stop fear, remove grief, create joy and increase pity. The soul under persuasion is like a body under a drug. He ends by calling the speech an encomium of Helen and an amusement for himself.
Against Plato's portrait. In Plato's Gorgias he is led to admit that rhetoric produces belief without knowledge, and is compared to pastry cooking, which pleases the palate without regard to health. The historical Gorgias seems to have thought something more interesting: that since knowledge of the truth is not available in most matters of public decision, persuasion is what we have, and its power needs to be understood. The claim that the audience of a tragedy is wiser for being deceived makes a similar point about fiction.
Works
- On Not-Being, or On Nature, known through two later summaries
- Encomium of Helen
- Defence of Palamedes
Influenced by
Empedocles, Parmenides, Zeno of Elea
Influenced
Schools and eras
Further reading
Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Open Gorgias in the interactive Atlas, with lessons, quizzes, the map and the timeline.