Atlas of Philosophy

All entries › Philosophers

Hans-Georg Gadamer

1900 CE – 2002 CE · Marburg and Heidelberg, Germany · European

German philosopher who developed hermeneutics into a general account of understanding as a dialogue with tradition.

Life

Gadamer was born in Marburg, studied classical philology and philosophy, and became a student of Martin Heidegger in the 1920s. He remained in Germany through the Nazi period, holding academic posts without joining the party, and was rector at Leipzig after the war.

From 1949 he taught at Heidelberg. He published his major work, Truth and Method, at sixty, and remained active as a lecturer and writer until his death at 102.

Core ideas

In more depth

The question. Gadamer asks what happens when we understand a text, a work of art or another person. His claim is that understanding is not a method to be applied. It is the way human beings exist in the world, and the human sciences misunderstand themselves when they model their work on the natural sciences.

Prejudice rehabilitated. The Enlightenment had a prejudice against prejudice. Gadamer argues that we always approach anything with fore-judgements given by our language and tradition. These are not simply obstacles. They are the conditions of understanding anything at all. Some turn out to be legitimate and some not, and they are tested in the encounter with what we are trying to understand.

The hermeneutic circle. We grasp the parts of a text in light of an anticipation of the whole and revise that anticipation as we read. The circle is not vicious. It describes how understanding proceeds.

Effective history. We stand within the history of effects of the works we interpret. A classic text has shaped the very assumptions with which we read it. We can become aware of this situation but can never survey it completely from outside.

Fusion of horizons. Each interpreter has a horizon, the range of vision from a particular standpoint. To understand is not to abandon one's own horizon for the author's. It is a fusion in which both are altered. The meaning of a text therefore goes beyond what its author intended, and understanding always includes application to the interpreter's situation, as a judge applies a law.

Dialogue and language. The model is conversation, in which the partners are led by the subject matter. Being that can be understood is language.

The debate with Habermas. Habermas objected that tradition can be a vehicle of domination and distortion, and that a critical standpoint is needed. Gadamer replied that critique too stands within tradition and language. The exchange defined the options for a generation.

The long life. Gadamer was born in 1900, studied with Heidegger in the 1920s, and trained also as a classical philologist; his lifelong subject was Plato. He stayed in Germany under the Nazis without joining the party, served briefly as rector at Leipzig under Soviet occupation, and moved to Heidelberg. Truth and Method appeared when he was sixty. He went on lecturing and debating into his nineties and died at 102.

Art and play. The book begins with art because art is a case where truth is experienced that method cannot capture. Gadamer's model is play. A game has its own to-and-fro movement which takes the players up into itself; the players do not control it. A work of art is play that has taken on lasting form. It exists only in being performed or read, and each performance is the work itself and not a copy. Understanding a work is taking part in an event.

Question and answer. To understand a text is to understand the question to which it is an answer. Gadamer takes this from Collingwood and from Plato's dialogues. The interpreter must work out that question, and in doing so finds that the text puts a question to him. Real questioning requires knowing that one does not know. Understanding has the structure of a conversation in which neither partner is in charge and the subject matter leads.

Application. Legal interpretation is Gadamer's model for all interpretation. A judge does not first understand the law and then apply it. Understanding what the statute means is working out what it requires in this case. The same holds for a preacher with Scripture and for a historian with a source. Meaning is always meaning for a situation, and so a text is understood differently wherever it is understood at all.

Derrida and the limits. At a meeting in Paris in 1981 Derrida asked whether Gadamer's good will to understand is not itself a form of the will to power, and whether understanding does not involve a break. Gadamer replied that even to ask the question is to wish to be understood. The exchange is usually described as a conversation that did not take place.

Works

A common misreading

Despite its title, Truth and Method does not offer a method for interpretation. Its argument is that truth in art, history and the humanities is not reached by scientific method.

Influenced by

Martin Heidegger, Plato, Aristotle, G.W.F. Hegel

Influenced

Jürgen Habermas, Jacques Derrida

Schools and eras

Phenomenology, Continental

Further reading

Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy

Open Hans-Georg Gadamer in the interactive Atlas, with lessons, quizzes, the map and the timeline.

This page is part of the philosophers list. How this content was made, and its limits, are described in the Terms of use.