Atlas of Philosophy

All entries › Ideas

Mary's room

Jackson's thought experiment suggesting that knowing all the physical facts leaves out what experience is like.

Also known as: The knowledge argument, Qualia

Explanation

Mary is a brilliant scientist who has lived her whole life in a black-and-white room. From books and a monochrome screen she has learned every physical fact about colour vision: wavelengths, the retina, the brain. One day she leaves the room and sees a ripe tomato. Does she learn something? It seems she learns what it is like to see red.

Frank Jackson argued in 1982 that if she learns something, then she did not know everything before. But she knew all the physical facts. So there are facts that are not physical. The qualities of experience that the argument turns on are called qualia.

Critics

David Lewis replied that Mary gains an ability, to recognise and imagine red, and no new fact. Others say she comes to know an old fact in a new way. Daniel Dennett denies that she would be surprised at all. Jackson himself later abandoned the argument.

Daniel Dennett, David Lewis

Where scholars disagree

The argument is among the most discussed in the philosophy of mind, and each of the main replies has defenders.

Related ideas

The hard problem of consciousness, Functionalism, Mind–body dualism

Further reading

Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy

Open Mary's room in the interactive Atlas, with lessons, quizzes, the map and the timeline.

This page is part of the ideas list. How this content was made, and its limits, are described in the Terms of use.