Watsuji Tetsurō
Japanese philosopher who made ethics the study of the betweenness of persons, and studied how climate shapes culture.
Life
Watsuji was a doctor's son who studied philosophy in Tokyo, wrote early books on Friedrich Nietzsche and Søren Kierkegaard, and then turned to Japanese and Buddhist culture. He was invited to Kyoto by Nishida Kitarō and later held the chair of ethics at Tokyo. He read Martin Heidegger's Being and Time in Berlin in 1927, the year it appeared. His wartime writings supported the emperor system, and his standing after 1945 was affected by them.
Core ideas
- A human being is individual and social at once; ethics concerns the space between persons.
- The Japanese word for human being, ningen, means literally “between persons”.
- Human existence is spatial as well as temporal.
- Climate and landscape are part of how a people understands itself.
- Ethical life is a movement of negation: the individual separates from the group and returns to it.
In more depth
Against the isolated individual. Western ethics, Watsuji argued, starts from the individual consciousness and then asks how it relates to others. This is an abstraction. We are from the first sons and daughters, friends, colleagues, citizens. The Japanese word ningen, written with characters meaning “person” and “between”, names this double character. Ethics is the order of the betweenness in which we already live, and its central phenomenon is trust: the driver trusts that others will keep to their side of the road, the passenger trusts the driver. Truthfulness is the response to trust.
Double negation. A person becomes an individual by standing apart from the group, negating the whole. But an individual who stops there is merely selfish. The ethical movement is completed when the individual negates this separateness and returns to the community, now freely. Watsuji describes this in Buddhist terms as emptiness realising itself. The danger is plain, and critics have pressed it: the scheme gives the community the last word, and in the 1940s he applied it to the state and the emperor.
Climate. Heidegger had analysed human existence in terms of time and neglected space. On his voyage to Europe, Watsuji was struck by how differently people live in different climates. He distinguished three types. In the monsoon lands of South and East Asia, heat and humidity bring abundance and violent storms, and people are receptive and resigned. In the desert, nature is death and life is a struggle, and people are combative and bound to the tribe and its one God. In the meadow lands of Europe, nature is mild and regular, and people become rational and seek to master it. The book is criticised as environmental determinism, but its claim that we encounter ourselves in our surroundings has lasted.
Works
- Pilgrimages to the Ancient Temples, 1919
- Climate and Culture (Fūdo), 1935
- Ethics (Rinrigaku), 1937–1949
Influenced by
Martin Heidegger, Nishida Kitarō, Friedrich Nietzsche, Søren Kierkegaard, Dōgen, G.W.F. Hegel
Schools and eras
Kyoto School, 20th-Century Global
Further reading
Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Open Watsuji Tetsurō in the interactive Atlas, with lessons, quizzes, the map and the timeline.