Sor Juana Inés de la Cruz
Mexican nun, poet and scholar who defended women's right to study.
Life
Juana Ramírez was born illegitimate on a hacienda near the volcanoes, taught herself to read at three in her grandfather's library, and as a girl asked to be sent to the university dressed as a boy. She became a lady-in-waiting at the viceroy's court, where she is said to have been examined by forty scholars. At about twenty she entered the Hieronymite convent, which let her keep a library and instruments. After a conflict with church authorities she sold her books, and died nursing her sisters in an epidemic.
Core ideas
- The intellect has no sex; women have the same capacity and right to learn as men.
- All the sciences are linked, and the lower ones are steps to theology.
- Knowledge can be gained by observing ordinary things, even in the kitchen.
- The human mind cannot grasp the whole of reality at a single glance, yet is right to strive.
- Older learned women should teach girls.
In more depth
The Reply. In 1690 the Bishop of Puebla published, without her leave, a critique she had written of a famous sermon, and added a letter under the name Sister Filotea advising her to give up worldly learning. Her answer is an intellectual autobiography and a defence. From childhood her desire for knowledge was so strong that she cut her hair as a penalty when she had not learned a thing quickly enough. She entered the convent because she wished to live alone with her books. She lists learned women of the Bible, antiquity and the Church, and interprets St Paul's command that women keep silent in church as a ban on preaching, not on study.
Philosophy in the kitchen. Forbidden books for a time by a superior, she writes, she studied the things God made. She observed that an egg holds together and fries in fat but falls apart in syrup, and watched the lines traced by a spinning top in scattered flour to see whether they were circles or spirals. “If Aristotle had cooked, he would have written much more.” The passage argues, with humour, that inquiry is a natural activity of the mind and that the conditions of women's lives are not opposed to it.
First Dream. Her long philosophical poem describes the soul, freed during sleep while the body rests, rising like a pyramid to survey all creation. It tries first to grasp everything in one intuition and is dazzled and falls back. It then tries method, ascending step by step through the kinds of being, from stones to plants to animals to the human, and finds that it cannot understand even a single flower or the course of a spring. Dawn comes, the senses wake, and the poem ends: “and I awake”. The poem has been read as a statement of the limits of knowledge and as a vindication of the attempt.
Works
- Allegorical Neptune, 1680
- Athenagoric Letter, 1690
- Reply to Sor Filotea, written 1691
- First Dream, published 1692
Influenced by
Aristotle, Thomas Aquinas, Augustine of Hippo
Schools and eras
Further reading
Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Open Sor Juana Inés de la Cruz in the interactive Atlas, with lessons, quizzes, the map and the timeline.