Simone Weil
French philosopher, labour activist and mystic, who wrote on attention, affliction, force and obligation.
Life
Weil came from a secular Jewish family; her brother André became a great mathematician. She studied under the philosopher Alain, taught in girls' schools, and in 1934 took a year's leave to work in factories. She went briefly to the Spanish Civil War. From 1938 a series of religious experiences drew her toward Christianity, though she refused baptism. She joined the Free French in London and died in a sanatorium in Kent at thirty-four, having restricted her eating.
Core ideas
- Attention, a waiting and self-emptying openness, is the substance of prayer, of study and of love of neighbour.
- Affliction is suffering that uproots a life and marks the soul with slavery.
- Force turns anyone subjected to it into a thing.
- Obligations come before rights.
- To be rooted is the most important and least recognised need of the human soul.
In more depth
The factory. Weil wanted to know what industrial work does to a person. On the assembly line at Renault she found that the worst of it was not pain or fatigue but the destruction of thought. The pace and the fear of the foreman made her a docile beast of burden, she wrote, who no longer dared to raise her eyes. Oppression lies in the organisation of work itself, in the separation of those who direct from those who execute, and would survive a change of ownership. She had criticised Marx on this point before she went.
Attention. A geometry problem one fails to solve is not wasted if one has truly attended to it. Attention means suspending one's thought, leaving it empty and ready to be entered by its object. The same capacity, turned toward a suffering person, is the rarest form of generosity: to be able to ask, what are you going through? Most people, faced with the afflicted, look away. To attend is to consent to the other's full existence.
Force. Her essay on the Iliad reads it as a poem whose true hero is force. Force is what makes a person into a thing: at the limit a corpse, short of that a suppliant or a slave. It also deceives those who wield it, who believe it is theirs and are destroyed in turn. The poem's greatness is that it grieves for Greeks and Trojans alike. The essay was written as France fell.
Decreation and roots. In her religious notebooks God creates by withdrawing, and the creature's task is to consent to become nothing so that God may love through it. She speaks of gravity, the downward pull of self-regard, and of grace. Her last book, written for the Free French as a plan for France after the war, begins from obligations to human needs: for food and shelter, and also for order, liberty, responsibility, truth, and roots in a community with a past.
Works
- Reflections Concerning the Causes of Liberty and Social Oppression, 1934
- The Iliad, or the Poem of Force, 1940
- Gravity and Grace, published 1947
- The Need for Roots, written 1943; published 1949
- Waiting for God, published 1950
Influenced by
Plato, Immanuel Kant, René Descartes, Karl Marx
Influenced
Albert Camus, Emmanuel Levinas
Schools and eras
Further reading
Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Open Simone Weil in the interactive Atlas, with lessons, quizzes, the map and the timeline.