Saadia Gaon
Head of the academy of Sura and author of the first systematic work of Jewish philosophy.
Life
Saadia was born in Egypt and made his name young with a Hebrew dictionary and a polemic against the Karaites, who rejected rabbinic tradition. In 928 he was appointed gaon, head of the ancient academy of Sura in Iraq, the first outsider to hold the office. A quarrel with the exilarch led to his deposition for several years, during which he wrote his philosophical work. He also translated the Bible into Arabic.
Core ideas
- Knowledge has four sources: sense perception, self-evident reason, inference, and reliable tradition.
- Reason and revelation agree, and revelation gives quickly what reason reaches slowly.
- The world was created from nothing, as four arguments show.
- Commandments are of two kinds: those reason requires and those known only by revelation.
- God is one and incorporeal; scriptural language of body is figurative.
In more depth
Why philosophise. The Book of Beliefs and Opinions begins with the sources of doubt and the ways of removing it. If the truths of religion have been revealed, why inquire? Saadia gives two reasons: to make actual in our own understanding what we have received from the prophets, and to answer those who attack the faith. Inquiry takes time and many are not capable of it, so God in his mercy sent the conclusions ahead through revelation. His method and many of his arguments come from the Mu'tazilite theologians of Islam.
Four arguments for creation. The world is finite, so the force that keeps it in being is finite and cannot have sustained it for ever. The world is composed of parts, and what is composed has a composer. Bodies are never free of accidents that come and go, and what cannot exist without things that begin must itself have begun. And if past time were infinite, it could not have been crossed to reach the present. He then argues that the creator made the world from nothing, since a pre-existing matter would be a second eternal thing.
Two kinds of law. Some commandments reason itself would dictate: gratitude to a benefactor, and the prohibitions of murder, theft and falsehood. Others, such as the Sabbath and the dietary laws, reason neither requires nor forbids; they are known by hearing, and give an added opportunity for obedience and reward, though they often have discernible uses. Tradition is needed for both, to fix the details. On the suffering of the innocent he held that it is compensated in the world to come. Moses Maimonides later rejected the idea that any commandments are rational in Saadia's sense.
Works
- Commentary on the Book of Creation, 931
- The Book of Beliefs and Opinions, 933
- Arabic translation of the Bible
Influenced by
Influenced
Schools and eras
Further reading
Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Open Saadia Gaon in the interactive Atlas, with lessons, quizzes, the map and the timeline.