Nagarjuna
Founder of the Madhyamaka school of Buddhism, who argued that all things are empty of intrinsic nature.
Life
Nagarjuna is thought to have lived in southern India in about the second century CE, possibly under the patronage of a king of the Satavahana dynasty. The traditional biographies were written centuries later and are full of legend, including a visit to the realm of serpent spirits to recover hidden scriptures.
His principal work, the Fundamental Verses on the Middle Way, examines one concept after another, such as causation, motion, the self and time, and argues that each is incoherent if taken to refer to something existing independently.
Core ideas
- Śūnyatā (emptiness): all phenomena are empty of svabhava, intrinsic or independent nature.
- Emptiness is not nothingness; it is the same as Dependent origination.
- Two truths: conventional truth, which governs everyday life, and ultimate truth, that nothing has intrinsic nature.
- Emptiness is itself empty, and is not to be held as a view.
- Arguments by reductio that draw out contradictions in an opponent's position without asserting a rival thesis.
In more depth
The thesis. Nagarjuna's central claim is that all things are empty of svabhava, a term meaning own-being or intrinsic nature: existence that a thing would have by itself, independently of anything else. Earlier Buddhist scholastics had analysed the world into ultimate constituents, dharmas, each with its own nature. Nagarjuna argues that even these are empty.
Why. Whatever arises in dependence on causes and conditions cannot have intrinsic nature, since intrinsic nature would be uncaused and unchanging. And everything arises dependently. So emptiness and dependent origination are the same fact seen from two sides. He writes that for whom emptiness is possible, everything is possible: only because things lack fixed natures can change, causation and the Buddhist path occur.
The method. The Fundamental Verses examine one category after another, causation, motion, the self, time, and show that each leads to absurdity if its terms are taken to have intrinsic nature. Often he uses a fourfold scheme, rejecting that a thing is, is not, both, or neither. On causation: a thing does not arise from itself, from another, from both or from no cause.
Two truths. The Buddha's teaching relies on two truths: conventional truth, which concerns the everyday world of persons and things, and ultimate truth, which is emptiness. The ultimate is not taught without relying on the conventional. Emptiness is therefore not a denial of the ordinary world.
Emptiness is empty. Emptiness is not a higher reality behind appearances. It too is dependently designated. He warns that emptiness wrongly grasped is like a snake picked up by the wrong end, and that those for whom emptiness becomes a view are incurable.
No thesis. Opponents objected that if all statements are empty, so is his, and it cannot refute anything. He replies, in the Dispeller of Disputes, that he has no thesis of his own with intrinsic nature and so incurs no fault, and that his words work as one illusion may stop another.
Readings. He has been interpreted as a nihilist, a sceptic, a mystic and an anti-foundationalist. Later Tibetan scholars divided his followers according to whether they advanced independent arguments.
The dedication. The Fundamental Verses on the Middle Way open by saluting the Buddha as the teacher of dependent origination, described by eight negations: no ceasing and no arising, no annihilation and no permanence, no identity and no difference, no coming and no going. The work has twenty-seven short chapters, each examining a topic such as causes, motion, the senses, the self, time and nirvana. Little is known of the author, who probably lived in South India around the second century CE.
Four alternatives. The first verse states that nothing arises from itself, from another, from both, or without a cause. If a thing arose from itself it would already exist, and arising would be pointless. If from something wholly other, anything could arise from anything. Both together inherits both problems; neither makes arising random. The same pattern of rejecting four options is applied throughout. It is aimed at the assumption that causes and effects have their own fixed natures.
The walker. Chapter 2 examines motion. Motion is not found on the path already traversed, nor on the path not yet traversed; and apart from these there is no path being traversed. Nor is there a mover apart from moving, or a moving apart from a mover, and they cannot be the same. Some have compared this to Zeno. The aim differs: Nagarjuna does not deny that people walk. He denies that walker, walking and path exist each by its own nature.
The key verses. Chapter 24 imagines an objector: if all is empty, there are no four truths, no path, no Buddha. Nagarjuna turns it round. It is for one who holds that things have intrinsic nature that nothing could arise or cease, and so the truths would be impossible. Whatever is dependently arisen is what we call emptiness; it is a dependent designation, and it is the middle way. And in chapter 25: there is not the slightest difference between cyclic existence and nirvana.
The warning. Emptiness wrongly grasped destroys the slow-witted, like a snake seized by the wrong end. Those for whom emptiness itself becomes a view are declared incurable. In Tibet the dispute between readings associated with Buddhapalita and Chandrakirti on one side and Bhavaviveka on the other, over whether a Madhyamika may advance arguments of his own, became a central topic of scholastic training.
Works
- Fundamental Verses on the Middle Way (Mulamadhyamakakarika), c. 2nd century CE
- Dispeller of Disputes (Vigrahavyavartani), c. 2nd century CE
Where scholars disagree
Interpreters disagree about whether Nagarjuna holds any positive position, and whether his arguments are anti-realist, sceptical or a form of therapy for attachment to views.
A common misreading
Nagarjuna is often called a nihilist. He explicitly rejects the view that nothing exists, and warns that emptiness wrongly grasped is like a snake picked up by the wrong end.
Influenced by
Siddhartha Gautama (the Buddha)
Influenced
Vasubandhu, Dignaga, Dōgen, Nishida Kitarō
Related ideas
Schools and eras
Further reading
Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Open Nagarjuna in the interactive Atlas, with lessons, quizzes, the map and the timeline.