Atlas of Philosophy

All entries › Philosophers

Vasubandhu

c. 350 CE – c. 430 CE · Gandhara (present-day Peshawar, Pakistan); northern India · Indian

Buddhist philosopher who systematised the earlier scholastic tradition and then argued, as a founder of Yogacara, that experience is “consciousness only”.

Life

Vasubandhu was born in Gandhara, in the north-west of the Indian subcontinent, and trained in the Sarvastivada school of Buddhist scholasticism. His Treasury of Abhidharma became the standard compendium of that tradition, though his own commentary on it criticises many of its doctrines.

According to the traditional account, his half-brother Asanga converted him to the Mahayana, after which he wrote the short treatises that are classics of the Yogacara school. He is said to have enjoyed the patronage of the Gupta court.

Core ideas

In more depth

Abhidharma. Vasubandhu's Treasury of Abhidharma sets out in verse the system that analyses experience into momentary constituents, dharmas, and classifies them. His own prose commentary criticises that system on many points. Against the school's doctrine that past and future dharmas exist, he argues that only the present does. A chapter refutes the self, and also the view of some Buddhists that there is an inexpressible person.

Momentariness. Things do not endure. They perish as soon as they arise, without needing an external cause of destruction, since if a thing did not perish by itself nothing could make it. What we call a lasting object is a series of similar events.

Appearance only. The Twenty Verses argue that what we take for external objects is nothing but appearance in consciousness, as a person with an eye disease sees hairs that are not there. He takes the objections in turn. Why are experiences fixed to place and time? So they are in dreams. Why do many beings see the same thing? Beings in hell see the same torments because of similar karma. How can unreal objects have effects? Dreams have effects on the body.

Against atoms. External objects would have to be made of atoms. But a partless atom cannot combine with others: if six join it on six sides it has six parts, and if they all occupy one place the aggregate is no larger than an atom. So the object is neither one thing nor many.

The transformation of consciousness. The Thirty Verses give the positive account. Beneath the six kinds of sense consciousness and the self-regarding mind lies a store consciousness that carries the seeds left by past action, which ripen as future experience. This explains continuity and karma without a self.

Three natures. Things can be viewed as imagined, the falsely constructed duality of subject and object; as dependent, the flow of causally conditioned appearance; and as perfected, the dependent seen free of that duality.

Dispute. Whether he denies that anything exists outside mind, or only describes how experience is constructed, divides modern interpreters. Some hold that two authors of the same name are involved.

The tradition of the life. A biography preserved in Chinese says that Vasubandhu was born in Gandhara, in the north-west of the subcontinent, became a monk in the Sarvastivada school and mastered its Abhidharma, and was later converted to the Mahayana by his half-brother Asanga, after which he wrote commentaries on Mahayana sutras. Because the works attributed to him are so varied, one twentieth-century scholar proposed that there were two Vasubandhus. Most scholars now accept one author.

Against the person. The last chapter of the Treasury refutes the view of a Buddhist school that a person exists in addition to the aggregates and is neither the same as them nor different. Whatever exists, Vasubandhu argues, is known by perception or inference. A person is known by neither, apart from the aggregates. When we speak of someone remembering, there is only a later mental event caused by an earlier one in the same series. A flame “moves” though it is a succession of flames.

The objections to mind-only. The Twenty Verses face four objections. If there are no external objects, why do experiences occur at particular places and times, why do different people share them, and why do experienced things have effects? Vasubandhu answers with dreams, in which place and time are determined and effects occur, and with the hells, where many beings see the same guards and rivers because of the similar ripening of their past actions, though no guards exist.

The store consciousness. The Thirty Verses describe three transformations of consciousness. The first is the store consciousness, which carries the seeds of all past actions and flows on like a river. The second is the mentation that takes the store for a self. The third is the six kinds of perception. When the store is transformed at its root and no object is grasped, there is neither grasper nor grasped. This is the revolution of the basis.

Readings. The claim that all this is appearance only has been read as idealism, the denial of matter, and as a more modest claim that we never experience objects apart from our constructions of them. Vasubandhu ends the Twenty Verses by saying that the full scope of the doctrine is beyond thought and is known only to Buddhas.

Works

Where scholars disagree

The historian Erich Frauwallner proposed that there were two Vasubandhus, an earlier Yogacara author and a later author of the Treasury. Most scholars now accept a single author, but the question is not closed.

A common misreading

“Consciousness only” is often equated with the claim that nothing exists except one's own mind. Vasubandhu accepts other streams of consciousness, and many interpreters read him as describing experience and not denying an external world outright.

Influenced by

Siddhartha Gautama (the Buddha), Nagarjuna

Influenced

Dignaga

Schools and eras

Yogacara, Classical Indian

Further reading

Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy

Open Vasubandhu in the interactive Atlas, with lessons, quizzes, the map and the timeline.

This page is part of the philosophers list. How this content was made, and its limits, are described in the Terms of use.