Atlas of Philosophy

All entries › Philosophers

Wang Yangming

1472 CE – 1529 CE · Zhejiang, China · Chinese

Ming dynasty scholar-general who taught that moral knowledge is innate in the mind and inseparable from action.

Also known as: Wang Shouren, 王陽明

Life

Wang was born in Zhejiang, the son of a high official. As a young man he tried to follow Zhu Xi's method by contemplating bamboo for days in search of its principle, and made himself ill. In 1506 he protested against a powerful court eunuch, was flogged, and was banished to a remote post in Guizhou, where he had a sudden insight that principle is to be sought in the mind.

He went on to a distinguished career as an administrator and military commander, suppressing several rebellions, including that of an imperial prince in 1519, while teaching a growing body of students.

Core ideas

In more depth

The mind is principle. Zhu Xi had taught that the principles of things must be investigated one by one. Wang Yangming tried this as a young man, by his own account contemplating bamboo for days until he fell ill. He concluded that principle is not to be sought in external things. The mind itself is principle. The principle of filial devotion is not found in one's parents; it is in the mind that serves them.

Unity of knowledge and action. People say that someone knows he ought to be filial and yet is not. Wang denies that this is knowledge. Knowledge is the beginning of action and action the completion of knowledge. To see a beautiful colour is already to like it, and to smell a bad odour is already to dislike it. There has never been one who knows and does not act; those who do not act simply do not yet know. A thought of evil is already the beginning of doing it.

Innate knowing. Everyone has liangzhi, a term from Mencius meaning the knowledge one has without reflection or study. For Wang it is an inborn, immediate awareness of right and wrong, the same in a sage and a fool, though obscured by selfish desire. Moral cultivation is the extension of innate knowing: bringing it to bear on each situation and acting on it sincerely. Investigating things, on his reading, means rectifying one's affairs.

One body. The humane person regards heaven, earth and the myriad things as one body. Alarm at a child falling into a well shows our unity with the child, pity at the cry of an animal our unity with animals, and regret at a broken tile our unity even with those.

The Four Sentences. He summed up his teaching: in the mind's original substance there is no good or evil; when intentions stir there is good and evil; innate knowing is what knows good and evil; investigating things is doing good and removing evil. His students disagreed at once about the first line.

Criticism. Opponents said the doctrine made each person's feeling the judge of right and resembled Chan Buddhism. Some of his later followers did draw radical conclusions. His thought was influential in Japan.

The life. Wang Yangming lived from 1472 to 1529 under the Ming. He was an official and a successful general. In 1506, having defended officials who criticised a powerful eunuch, he was beaten in court and exiled to a remote post at Longchang in Guizhou. There, one night, he came to the realisation that his own nature is sufficient and that it had been a mistake to seek principle in external things. He later put down a prince's rebellion and several uprisings.

The bamboo. As a young man Wang took Zhu Xi at his word. He and a friend sat before the bamboo in his father's garden to investigate its principle. The friend fell ill after three days, and Wang after seven. He concluded then that sagehood was beyond them. Years later he saw the error differently: the effort was aimed in the wrong direction. To investigate things is to rectify what is not right in the mind's own responses.

Seeing and loving. To show that knowledge and action are one, Wang cites the Great Learning: like loving a beautiful colour, like hating a bad smell. Seeing the colour belongs to knowing and loving it to acting, but one does not first see and then decide to love. A person who says he knows filial piety and does not practise it does not yet know it. Knowledge is the beginning of action, and action the completion of knowledge.

The child and the tile. The great man regards heaven, earth and the ten thousand things as one body. When he sees a child about to fall into a well he feels alarm; that shows his humaneness is one with the child. But he also cannot bear the cry of birds about to be killed, feels pity at broken plants, and regret at shattered tiles and stones. The sense of one body is there in everyone and is obscured by selfish desire.

The Tianquan bridge. The Four Sentences say: no good and no evil is the substance of the mind; good and evil arise with the movement of intention; knowing good and evil is innate knowing; doing good and removing evil is the rectification of things. Two disciples disagreed over whether the first line means that effort is needed. Wang said each reading suits a different kind of student. His school spread widely and was influential in Japan.

Works

Where scholars disagree

Critics in his own time and since have charged that his teaching is Chan Buddhism in Confucian dress. His followers split over whether innate knowledge needs disciplined effort to realise.

A common misreading

Wang did not reject study or tradition. His complaint was against learning pursued as accumulation of information, cut off from moral practice.

Influenced by

Mencius, Zhu Xi, Confucius

Related ideas

Unity of knowledge and action

Schools and eras

Neo-Confucianism, Confucianism, Post-Classical East Asian

Further reading

Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy

Open Wang Yangming in the interactive Atlas, with lessons, quizzes, the map and the timeline.

This page is part of the philosophers list. How this content was made, and its limits, are described in the Terms of use.