Ludwig Feuerbach
German philosopher who explained religion as the projection of human nature, and stands between Hegel and Marx.
Life
Feuerbach studied theology, then went to Berlin to hear G.W.F. Hegel. An anonymous early book denying personal immortality ended his academic prospects when its authorship became known. He lived for decades in a Bavarian village, supported by his wife's share in a porcelain factory. The Essence of Christianity, of 1841, was the book of its generation; George Eliot translated it into English.
Core ideas
- Theology is anthropology: what people worship as God is their own nature set outside themselves.
- In religion people impoverish themselves to enrich God.
- Speculative philosophy is theology in disguise and must be turned right side up.
- The starting point of philosophy is the sensuous, embodied human being.
- The human essence exists only in community, in the relation of I and thou.
In more depth
The projection. Human beings differ from animals in being conscious of their species: of reason, will and love as perfections without limit. Each individual is limited, but the species is not. In religion these perfections are gathered and set before the mind as a separate being. God is all-knowing, all-loving and just because knowledge, love and justice are what humans value in themselves. The attributes are true; the mistake is to assign them to another subject. To correct it, reverse subject and predicate: not “God is love” but “love is divine”.
Alienation. The more people attribute to God, the less they leave to themselves. For God to be everything, man must be nothing. Feuerbach did not regard himself as an enemy of the content of religion. He wanted to restore to human beings what they had given away, and to turn the love of God into love of humanity. The second half of the book argues that theology, by taking the projection literally, produces contradictions and intolerance.
Against Hegel. Hegel's philosophy begins with abstract thought and derives nature and humanity from it. Feuerbach says this is the old theology in rational dress: absolute spirit is the departed spirit of theology. Thought comes from being, not being from thought. Philosophy should begin with what is finite, particular and sensuous. He put the point crudely in a pun: man is what he eats.
Marx's verdict. Marx and Engels were, for a moment, all Feuerbachians. Marx then objected that Feuerbach explains why people project a heaven but not why their earthly life is such that they need one, and that he treats human nature as a fixed essence in each individual. The world must not only be understood as the basis of religion; it must be changed. Søren Kierkegaard and later theologians such as Barth took Feuerbach seriously as the critic religion has to answer.
Works
- Thoughts on Death and Immortality, 1830
- The Essence of Christianity, 1841
- Principles of the Philosophy of the Future, 1843
- The Essence of Religion, 1846
Influenced by
Influenced
Karl Marx, Friedrich Nietzsche
Schools and eras
Further reading
Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Open Ludwig Feuerbach in the interactive Atlas, with lessons, quizzes, the map and the timeline.