Henri Bergson
French philosopher of time as lived duration, of intuition, and of a creative impulse in evolution.
Life
Bergson was born in Paris to a Polish Jewish musician and an English mother, excelled in mathematics, and chose philosophy. His lectures at the Collège de France drew such crowds that it was proposed to move them to the Opera. He undertook diplomatic missions in the First World War, chaired the League of Nations body that preceded UNESCO, and was awarded the 1927 Nobel Prize in Literature. In 1940 he declined exemption from the anti-Jewish laws.
Core ideas
- Real time is duration: a continuous flow in which states interpenetrate, not a line of separate instants.
- Science and the intellect spatialise time and so miss it.
- Intuition enters into a thing from within; analysis walks around it.
- Freedom is the act that expresses the whole person.
- Life is driven by a creative impulse, the élan vital, that produces genuine novelty.
In more depth
Duration. Listen to a melody. The notes do not sit side by side like beads; each is heard in the light of those before it, and the whole is a single movement. Stretch one note and the melody changes. That is how consciousness exists in time. When we think of time as a line divided into seconds, we have replaced it with space, where things are outside one another. Clock time is useful for measuring and acting. It is not the time we live. Bergson's example: to make sugared water, I must wait for the sugar to dissolve, and this waiting is not a mathematical quantity.
Freedom and Zeno. The usual debate asks whether, given the same antecedents, I could have chosen otherwise, and pictures a path that forks. But this lays out in space a process that only exists in becoming. A free act is one that springs from the whole personality, as a fruit ripens. Zeno's paradoxes arise from the same confusion: they treat a movement as the line it leaves behind, which can be divided, when the movement itself is an indivisible act.
Memory and the brain. Matter and Memory distinguishes habit memory, as in knowing a poem by heart, from pure recollection of unique past events. From studies of aphasia Bergson argued that memories are not stored in the brain. The brain is an organ of action that selects from the past what is useful now. Perception, likewise, is the body's sketch of its possible action on things.
The vital impulse and its critics. Evolution, he argued, cannot be explained by mechanism or by a fixed plan. It is the working of an original impetus that divides, like a shell bursting into fragments, along the lines of plant, instinct and intelligence. In 1922 he debated the nature of time with Einstein in Paris and was generally thought to have lost. His reputation fell sharply after the war; Gilles Deleuze later revived him.
Works
- Time and Free Will, 1889
- Matter and Memory, 1896
- Laughter, 1900
- Creative Evolution, 1907
- The Two Sources of Morality and Religion, 1932
Influenced by
Plotinus, Immanuel Kant, William James
Influenced
Gilles Deleuze, Maurice Merleau-Ponty, Alfred North Whitehead, Jean-Paul Sartre
Schools and eras
Further reading
Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Open Henri Bergson in the interactive Atlas, with lessons, quizzes, the map and the timeline.