The ship of Theseus
The puzzle of whether a thing whose parts are all gradually replaced remains the same thing.
Explanation
Plutarch reports that the Athenians preserved the ship in which Theseus returned from Crete, replacing each plank as it decayed, and that philosophers disputed whether it was the same ship. Thomas Hobbes sharpened the case. Suppose someone kept the old planks and, when all had been replaced, put them together again in the original order. Now there are two ships. Which is the ship of Theseus? Each has a claim: one by continuity of form and use, the other by sameness of matter.
The puzzle bears on rivers, cells, institutions and persons. Heraclitus's river is an early relative. The possible answers include: identity follows continuous history; identity follows matter; there is no fact of the matter; and there were two overlapping ships all along.
Critics
Some hold that ordinary objects persist by having different temporal parts at different times, so that the question is which series of parts we mean by the name. Others take the case to show that identity over time is partly a matter of convention.
Where scholars disagree
The Buddhist treatment of the chariot uses a similar case to argue that wholes are only designations.
Related ideas
Personal identity, Anātman (no-self)
Further reading
Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Open The ship of Theseus in the interactive Atlas, with lessons, quizzes, the map and the timeline.