Atlas of Philosophy

All entries › Ideas

Unity of knowledge and action

Wang Yangming's doctrine that genuine moral knowledge and action are a single thing.

Also known as: Zhi xing he yi, 知行合一

Explanation

It is common to suppose that we first learn what is right and then, as a separate step, do it. Wang Yangming denied this. Someone who says he knows he should care for his parents and does not do so does not yet know it. Knowledge is the beginning of action, and action is the completion of knowledge.

His examples are seeing a beautiful colour and smelling a foul odour. To see the colour as beautiful is already to like it; no further decision intervenes. Real moral knowledge is like that, a response of the whole person. Wang presented the doctrine as a cure for the habit, which he blamed on followers of Zhu Xi, of studying moral principles endlessly without practising them.

Critics

The obvious objection is weakness of will: people seem to know what is right and fail to do it. Wang answers that such knowledge has been obscured by selfish desire and is not knowledge in the full sense. The later thinker Wang Fuzhi argued that action comes first and is the source of knowledge.

Where scholars disagree

Whether the doctrine is a claim about all knowledge or only about moral knowledge, and whether it defines knowledge so as to make the claim true by stipulation, is debated.

Originator

Wang Yangming

Related ideas

Ren

Schools

Neo-Confucianism

Further reading

Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy

Open Unity of knowledge and action in the interactive Atlas, with lessons, quizzes, the map and the timeline.

This page is part of the ideas list. How this content was made, and its limits, are described in the Terms of use.