Atlas of Philosophy

All entries › Philosophers

Thales of Miletus

c. 624 BCE – c. 546 BCE · Miletus, Ionia · Greek and Roman

Traditionally the first Greek philosopher, who proposed that water is the origin of all things.

Also known as: Thales

Life

Thales lived in Miletus, a wealthy Greek port in Ionia. His dates are estimated from a solar eclipse of 585 BCE that Herodotus says he foretold. Ancient writers counted him among the Seven Sages and told stories of his practical skill in astronomy, geometry and engineering.

If he wrote anything, it was lost early. Our knowledge depends chiefly on Aristotle, who was himself working from hearsay and who presents Thales as the founder of the inquiry into nature.

Core ideas

In more depth

The question. Thales matters less for his answer than for the kind of question he asked. Earlier Greek accounts of the world, such as Hesiod's, told how the gods were born and fought. Thales asked instead what everything is made of, and he gave an answer that could be examined and disputed.

The claim. Aristotle, our main source, reports that Thales took water to be the principle of all things, and guesses at his reasons: food and seed are moist, and life depends on moisture. Whether Thales meant that things come from water or that they still are water in altered form is not known. The claim that the earth floats on water looks like an attempt to explain earthquakes without Poseidon.

All things full of gods. Aristotle reports that Thales said the magnet has soul because it moves iron, and suggests, more tentatively, that the saying that all things are full of gods may go back to him. Read together, these suggest that Thales did not separate matter from life as later thinkers did: the basic stuff is itself active.

How far we can trust this. Nothing Thales wrote survives, and Aristotle was writing some two centuries later with his own theory of causes in mind, into which he fitted his predecessors. The stories of the predicted eclipse and the measured pyramid are later still. What is secure is his reputation in antiquity as the first to inquire into nature in this way, and the fact that his fellow Milesians answered him with rival proposals.

Why water was a reasonable guess. Water is the one familiar stuff that is seen as solid, liquid and vapour. It falls from the sky, rises from the ground and is needed by every living thing. A thinker looking for a single material from which the variety of the world could come, by processes that could be observed, had better reasons to choose water than any other candidate. The answer was wrong, but it was the kind of answer that could be improved on, and his successors improved on it at once.

The practical man. The stories told about Thales pull in two directions. In one he falls into a well while looking at the stars, and a servant girl laughs at him for not seeing what is at his feet. In another, reported by Aristotle, he foresees a large olive harvest, hires all the presses in advance and makes a fortune, to show that philosophers could be rich if they cared to be. Both stories are about the standing of the new kind of inquiry and what use it is.

What was new. Thales did not invent curiosity about origins; the myths had it too. What changed was the form of the answer. It names an impersonal stuff, not a person. It appeals to features of the world that anyone can check. And it is offered as a claim that others may dispute, which they promptly did. The tradition of pupil criticising teacher, which Anaximander began by rejecting water, may be the most important thing to come out of Miletus.

Works

Where scholars disagree

Scholars disagree about whether Thales meant that everything is made of water or only that everything originally came from it.

A common misreading

Thales is often said to have predicted the eclipse of 585 BCE. Herodotus reports only that he foretold the year, and historians doubt that the astronomy of his day could have predicted a solar eclipse for a given place.

Influenced

Anaximander, Aristotle

Schools and eras

Pre-Socratic

Further reading

Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy

Open Thales of Miletus in the interactive Atlas, with lessons, quizzes, the map and the timeline.

This page is part of the philosophers list. How this content was made, and its limits, are described in the Terms of use.