Madhva
Founder of Dvaita Vedānta, the school that holds God, souls and matter to be eternally and really distinct.
Life
Madhva was born near Udupi on the west coast of India and became a renunciant as a boy. He broke with his Advaita teacher, travelled and debated across India, and founded at Udupi a temple of Krishna and a group of monasteries that still exist. His followers regard him as an incarnation of the wind god. He wrote commentaries on the Upanishads, the Gita and the Brahma Sutras, among some thirty-seven works.
Core ideas
- Difference is real and fivefold: between God and soul, God and matter, soul and soul, soul and matter, and one material thing and another.
- Vishnu alone is independent; everything else depends on him.
- The world is real and not an appearance.
- Souls differ by nature in their capacities and destinies.
- Liberation is the soul's blissful nearness to God, reached by devotion and grace.
In more depth
Against identity. Shankara read the Upanishads as teaching that the individual self is Brahman and that the world of difference is appearance. Ramanuja made selves and matter the body of God. Madhva goes further in the direction of plurality. Perception shows us a world of distinct things, and perception, when not defective, is a means of knowledge that scripture cannot overturn. If difference were unreal, the scripture that teaches non-difference would be unreal too. He reads the great sentence “that art thou” so that it affirms dependence, and by one division of the syllables as “thou art not that”.
Independent and dependent. Reality has two categories. The independent is God alone, identified with Vishnu, possessed of infinite excellent qualities. The dependent is everything else, souls and matter, which exist eternally and were never created out of nothing, yet at every moment depend on God for their being and activity. The relation is compared to that of an image and its original. To know oneself as a dependent reflection of God is the central insight.
Grades of souls. Souls are not alike. Each has an innate nature, and Madhva classifies them as fit for liberation, bound for ever to the cycle of rebirth, or destined for darkness. The idea of souls eternally excluded from release is unusual in Indian thought and has been much criticised; some scholars have suggested outside influence, which others reject. Even among the liberated there are degrees of bliss. Devotion, grounded in knowledge of God's greatness, is the means, and grace decides.
Works
- Commentary on the Brahma Sutras
- Anuvyākhyāna
- Commentary on the Bhagavad Gita
Influenced by
Related ideas
Moksha, Ātman–Brahman identity
Schools and eras
Further reading
Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Open Madhva in the interactive Atlas, with lessons, quizzes, the map and the timeline.