Shankara
The foremost exponent of Advaita Vedanta, who taught that the self is identical with Brahman, the one non-dual reality.
Life
Traditional biographies, written long after his death, say that Shankara was born in Kerala, became a renunciant as a boy, travelled the length of India debating rivals, founded monasteries in the four quarters of the country, and died at thirty-two.
Historians treat most of this with caution. What is secure is a body of commentaries, on the Brahma-sutra, the principal Upanishads and the Bhagavad Gita, that became the foundation of the Advaita tradition. Hundreds of other works carry his name, and most are of doubtful authorship.
Core ideas
- Brahman, pure consciousness without qualities, is the only ultimate reality.
- The individual self (atman) is not different from Brahman (see Ātman–Brahman identity).
- The world of plurality appears through ignorance (avidya), as a rope in dim light is mistaken for a snake.
- Liberation comes through knowledge alone, not through ritual action.
- Scripture is the source of this knowledge, with reasoning in its support.
In more depth
The claim. Shankara's teaching is summed up in a traditional verse: Brahman is real, the world is appearance, and the individual self is none other than Brahman. Brahman is pure, undifferentiated consciousness, without qualities, parts or change. The Upanishadic sentence that thou art states the identity.
Superimposition. He begins his chief commentary by asking how the self, which is the subject, could ever be confused with objects such as the body. Yet it is, constantly. This is adhyasa, superimposition: the appearance, in one thing, of the attributes of another, as when a rope in dim light is seen as a snake. Its cause is beginningless ignorance. All ordinary experience, with its distinctions of knower, knowing and known, rests on it.
Two levels. From the standpoint of everyday life, the world, the many selves and a personal God with attributes are real enough, and scripture, ritual and ethics apply. From the standpoint of ultimate truth there is only Brahman. The world is not sheer nothing, like the son of a barren woman. It is experienced and then sublated when knowledge dawns, as the snake is when the rope is seen.
Maya. The power by which the one appears as many is called maya. It cannot be described as real, since it is removed by knowledge, or as unreal, since it is experienced. Critics found this status unintelligible.
Liberation by knowledge. Since bondage is an error, only knowledge can end it. Works and devotion purify the mind but cannot produce liberation, which is not a new state to be brought about. It is the recognition of what one has always been, and can occur in this life.
Opponents. He argues against the Buddhists, the Samkhya dualists and the ritualists. Ramanuja later raised seven objections to his doctrine of ignorance, the first being that it has no possible location: not Brahman, which is knowledge, and not the individual, who is its product. Opponents called him a Buddhist in disguise.
The life in tradition. Shankara is said to have been born in Kerala, to have left home as a boy to become a renunciant, to have studied under Govinda, a pupil of Gaudapada, and to have travelled the length of India debating opponents and founding monasteries in the four quarters before dying at thirty-two. His certain works are commentaries on the Brahma Sutras, the principal Upanishads and the Bhagavad Gita, and an independent treatise, A Thousand Teachings.
That art thou. In the Chandogya Upanishad the sage Uddalaka teaches his son Shvetaketu by examples. Rivers flow into the sea and no longer know “I am this river”. A lump of salt dissolved in water cannot be seen, yet every sip is salty. That subtle essence is the self of all this; that is the real; that art thou. For Shankara this sentence, rightly understood, is itself the means of liberation. Scripture does not command anything here. It reveals what is already the case.
Rope and shell. In dim light a coiled rope is taken for a snake and causes real fear. When a lamp is brought, the snake is not destroyed; it is seen never to have been there. Mother-of-pearl is taken for silver. In each case something remembered is superimposed on what is present. The world of many things and the individual self are superimposed on Brahman in the same way. The snake is not real, since it is cancelled, and not wholly unreal, since it was experienced.
Three states. Shankara's tradition analyses waking, dream and deep sleep. In waking and dream there are objects and a knower. In deep sleep there are none, yet on waking one says: I slept well, I knew nothing. Something was present throughout as witness. That constant consciousness, not any of its changing contents, is the self. A fourth, which is not a state but the ground of the three, is the self as it is.
Qualifications and the ladder. A student must have discrimination between the eternal and the non-eternal, dispassion, calm and self-control, and a longing for release. Ritual and devotion purify the mind and prepare it; they do not themselves liberate. Critics from within Vedanta asked whose the ignorance is. It cannot be Brahman's, which is pure knowledge, nor the individual's, who is its product.
Works
- Commentary on the Brahma-sutra (Brahmasutrabhasya), c. 8th century CE
- Commentaries on the principal Upanishads and the Bhagavad Gita, c. 8th century CE
- A Thousand Teachings (Upadesasahasri), c. 8th century CE
Where scholars disagree
His traditional dates (788–820) are now generally thought too late. Critics in India called him a “crypto-Buddhist”, and how much Advaita owes to Madhyamaka and Yogacara Buddhism is still debated.
A common misreading
Shankara is often said to teach that the world is simply unreal. His position is that it is neither real in the way Brahman is nor unreal like a square circle; it has a provisional reality that is superseded by knowledge.
Influenced
Related ideas
Schools and eras
Advaita Vedanta, Classical Indian
Further reading
Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Open Shankara in the interactive Atlas, with lessons, quizzes, the map and the timeline.