Atlas of Philosophy

All entries › Philosophers

Ramanuja

c. 1017 CE – c. 1137 CE · Tamil Nadu, southern India · Indian

Theologian and philosopher of “qualified non-dualism”, who held that selves and the world are real and form the body of a personal God.

Also known as: Rāmānuja

Life

Ramanuja was born at Sriperumbudur near present-day Chennai and became the leading teacher of the Sri Vaishnava community, a tradition devoted to the god Vishnu, with its centre at the temple of Srirangam. Tradition says he was at one point forced into exile by a hostile king.

He set out to show that devotion to a personal God is the true teaching of the Upanishads. His major work is a commentary on the Brahma-sutra that argues in detail against Shankara's reading.

Core ideas

In more depth

Against non-dualism. Ramanuja accepts that Brahman alone is ultimately real but denies that it is without qualities or that the world and individual selves are illusory. A consciousness with no distinctions could not be known by any means of knowledge, since perception, inference and scripture all reveal objects as qualified. And if ignorance conceals Brahman, where is it located and what removes it?

Qualified non-dualism. His own position is that reality is one, but it is a unity that contains real distinctions. Individual selves and matter are real and eternally distinct from Brahman, yet inseparable from it and wholly dependent on it. They are its modes.

The body of God. The relation is that of body to soul. A body is whatever a conscious being entirely controls and supports for its own purposes. In that sense the whole universe of selves and matter is the body of Brahman, who is its inner self. Words that name things in the world therefore ultimately name Brahman as qualified by them, which is how he reads the sentence that thou art.

A personal God. Brahman is identified with Vishnu-Narayana, a person possessing infinite auspicious qualities such as knowledge, power and compassion. The scriptural passages that deny qualities deny only bad ones.

The self. Individual selves are atomic, conscious and many. Each is a knower and an agent, and its essential nature is to be dependent on and in service to God. Selfhood is not lost in liberation.

Devotion. Liberation comes through bhakti, loving devotion grounded in knowledge and supported by action, and finally through God's grace in response to the devotee's surrender. Liberation is eternal communion with God, not absorption.

Standing. His system gave philosophical form to the devotional religion of South India. Later Vedantins such as Madhva went further toward dualism. The tradition after him divided over whether grace requires any effort from the soul.

The life in tradition. Ramanuja was born near Madras and by tradition lived from 1017 to 1137. He studied first under an Advaita teacher, with whom he disagreed over the reading of the Upanishads, and then joined the Shrivaishnava community at the temple of Srirangam, which honoured both the Sanskrit scriptures and the Tamil hymns of the Alvar poet-saints. He is said to have been driven into exile for a time by a hostile king and to have organised temple worship in Karnataka.

Seven objections. The opening of his commentary on the Brahma Sutras sets out seven objections to the Advaita doctrine of ignorance. Where does it reside? Not in Brahman, which is pure knowledge; not in the individual, who exists only because of it. How can it conceal Brahman, whose nature is self-luminous? Is it real or unreal? If it is neither, it is indescribable, and what cannot be described cannot be established. By what means of knowledge is it known, and what could remove it?

How to read “that art thou”. Advaita reads the sentence as a bare identity, setting aside the differences between “that” and “thou”. Ramanuja reads it as he reads “the lotus is blue”: two terms with different meanings applied to one thing. Since every self is a mode of Brahman, as a body is of its soul, any word for a self refers finally to Brahman who has that self as his body. So “thou” denotes Brahman as the inner ruler of the hearer.

Knowledge is always of something qualified. Ramanuja denies that there can be awareness of pure, undifferentiated being. Every perception, even the first, grasps a thing as having some character; every sentence relates distinct words. So there is no evidence at all for a reality without qualities. Even error has an object: when shell is taken for silver, some real likeness to silver is seen. This is the basis of his realism about the world.

Surrender. Besides the disciplined devotion that requires study and meditation, his tradition teaches self-surrender to God, open to all regardless of caste or learning. After him the community divided over it. The northern school compared the soul to a baby monkey, which must cling to its mother; the southern school to a kitten, which the mother simply picks up.

Works

A common misreading

The traditional lifespan of 120 years is conventional and should not be taken literally. It is given here because no alternative dating is established.

Influenced by

Shankara

Schools and eras

Classical Indian

Further reading

Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy

Open Ramanuja in the interactive Atlas, with lessons, quizzes, the map and the timeline.

This page is part of the philosophers list. How this content was made, and its limits, are described in the Terms of use.