Desiderius Erasmus
The leading humanist of northern Europe, who urged a return to the sources of Christianity and defended free will against Luther.
Life
Erasmus was born in Rotterdam, the illegitimate son of a priest, and was ordained after an education in a monastery he disliked. He obtained leave to study in Paris and afterwards lived as an independent scholar, moving between the Low Countries, England, Italy and Basel.
His editions of classical and early Christian authors, and his Greek New Testament of 1516, made him the most famous scholar in Europe. He criticised abuses in the Church but refused to join the Reformation, and was attacked from both sides.
Core ideas
- The “philosophy of Christ”: religion is a matter of inward piety and moral conduct, not ceremonies or Scholastic subtleties.
- Education in classical literature forms character.
- War is almost never justified, and rulers should be trained for peace.
- Against Luther, the human will retains some power to cooperate with grace.
In more depth
The philosophy of Christ. Erasmus held that Christianity is above all a way of life, simple in its essentials and available to anyone who reads the Gospels. He contrasted this with the speculative theology of the schools, which he thought had buried the faith under disputes about questions nobody could settle. His programme was to return to the sources in their original languages, and his edition of the Greek New Testament was its main instrument.
Folly. The Praise of Folly is a speech delivered by Folly in her own honour. She claims credit for everything that makes life bearable, since self-love and illusion keep people going, then turns on theologians, monks, princes and popes, and ends by describing Christian devotion itself as a kind of folly in the eyes of the world. The irony allows sharp criticism while leaving it unclear how much the author endorses.
Free will. Against Luther he defended the freedom of the will. Scripture, he argued, is obscure on the question, and where it is obscure one should not make dogmatic assertions. It is enough to hold that grace does almost everything and that the will cooperates. To say the will does nothing removes the point of commands, rewards and punishments. Luther replied that Erasmus' moderation was itself a failure to take the matter seriously.
Peace and education. He argued that war among Christians is almost never justified and that a prince exists for the good of his people. His educational writings recommend gentle teaching through classical literature to form judgement and character.
Position. He stayed in the Catholic Church while criticising it, and was distrusted by both sides in the Reformation. His sceptical humility about doctrine and his plea for tolerance outlasted the quarrel.
The scholar's life. Erasmus was born in Rotterdam, the illegitimate son of a priest, and was pressed into a monastery as a young man. He obtained leave to study, never returned, and lived by his pen in Paris, England, Italy, Basel and Freiburg, refusing permanent posts. He was the first writer to become famous across Europe through the printing press. His collection of proverbs, the Adages, grew through successive editions to more than four thousand entries with commentary.
The Handbook. The Handbook of the Christian Soldier, of 1503, sets out his religious programme. True piety is inward. Outward observances such as fasting, pilgrimages, relics and the veneration of saints have value only as they lead to a change of heart, and when treated as ends they are a new kind of Judaism of ceremonies, as he puts it. The layman is called to holiness as much as the monk. “Monkhood is not piety” is its best-known sentence.
The debate in detail. In On Free Will (1524) Erasmus argues modestly. Scripture is obscure on the question; the tradition of the Church favours some freedom; and a doctrine that denies it will discourage effort and make God the author of evil. He would rather suspend judgement than assert. Luther's reply, The Bondage of the Will, attacks exactly that: a Christian delights in assertions, and the matter is not obscure. The exchange defined the difference between humanist reform and the Reformation.
The Complaint of Peace and the Colloquies. In The Complaint of Peace, Peace herself speaks, driven out from every court, church and household. War between Christians is fratricide; the worst peace is better than the most just war. The Colloquies, written as exercises in Latin conversation, became satirical dialogues on pilgrimages, superstition, marriage and bad inns, and were among the most read and most often banned books of the century. After his death all his works were placed on the Index.
Works
- Adages, 1500; much enlarged later
- The Praise of Folly, 1511
- The Education of a Christian Prince, 1516
- On Free Will, 1524
A common misreading
The saying that Erasmus “laid the egg that Luther hatched” was a taunt of his own day. Erasmus rejected it, and his dispute with Luther over free will shows how far apart they were.
Influenced by
Cicero, Seneca, Augustine of Hippo
Influenced
Schools and eras
Further reading
Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Open Desiderius Erasmus in the interactive Atlas, with lessons, quizzes, the map and the timeline.