Candrakīrti
Buddhist commentator on Nāgārjuna whose reading of emptiness became authoritative in Tibet.
Life
Almost nothing certain is known of Candrakīrti's life. He is associated with Nalanda, and legends tell of his milking a painted cow to show that things are not as solid as they seem. His commentary on Nagarjuna's Fundamental Verses is the only one to survive complete in Sanskrit. In India he was a minor figure; in Tibet, from the eleventh century, he became the standard interpreter.
Core ideas
- A Mādhyamika should not advance independent arguments but draw out the consequences of an opponent's views.
- Conventional truth is what the world accepts, and needs no philosophical foundation.
- Nothing has intrinsic nature, even conventionally.
- The self is neither identical with the aggregates nor different from them; it is a dependent designation.
- The mind-only teaching is provisional.
In more depth
Consequences, not theses. An earlier commentator, Bhāviveka, had held that a follower of Nāgārjuna must prove emptiness by formal arguments of his own, using the logic of Dignaga. Candrakīrti objects. A formal argument requires a subject that both parties accept as established. But the Mādhyamika and his opponent do not agree on what any subject is, since one takes it to have intrinsic nature and the other does not. All the Mādhyamika can do is show that the opponent's position leads to consequences the opponent himself rejects. Tibetan scholars named the two approaches after these methods.
The chariot in seven ways. To show that there is no self, Candrakīrti extends an old analysis. A chariot is not other than its parts, nor identical with them; it does not possess them, is not in them, nor are they in it; it is not their mere collection, nor their shape. Searched for in these seven ways it is not found. Yet the world speaks of chariots, and they carry people. So with the self: it is designated in dependence on the aggregates and functions in everyday life, while under analysis nothing is found.
The world's convention. For Candrakīrti conventional truth is simply what people in general accept without philosophical analysis: that seeds produce sprouts, that there are tables and persons. The Buddhist should not try to give these a deeper basis, whether in atoms or in consciousness. He criticises the Yogācāra view that mind is real while its objects are not: mind and object are equally dependent and equally empty. Critics ask whether this leaves any room to correct a mistaken convention. The Tibetan thinker Tsongkhapa built his system largely on answering that question.
Works
- Clear Words (Prasannapadā)
- Introduction to the Middle Way (Madhyamakāvatāra)
Influenced by
Nagarjuna, Siddhartha Gautama (the Buddha)
Related ideas
Śūnyatā (emptiness), Anātman (no-self)
Schools and eras
Further reading
Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Open Candrakīrti in the interactive Atlas, with lessons, quizzes, the map and the timeline.